Watershed water balance changes as furrow irrigation is converted to sprinkler irrigation in an arid region

Irrigation is the largest water use in the western United States. The Upper Snake Rock Conservation Effects Assessment Project in southern Idaho began in 2005 to quantify the impacts of conservation practices in this irrigated watershed. The objective of this study was to determine the changes in the watershed water balances as farmers converted furrow irrigated fields to sprinkler irrigation from 2006 to 2016. More than 75% of annual watershed inflow was irrigation water diverted into the watershed from the Snake River and distributed through canals to 82,000 ha of cropland, while annual precipitation was only 10% to 23% of the annual inflow. Approximately 30% of the annual watershed inflow flowed back to the Snake River as irrigation return flow. Water balances showed that irrigation exceeded evapotranspiration (ET) in the spring and fall, indicating that irrigation diversions could be reduced early and late in the irrigation season. Annual irrigation project efficiency, defined as ET divided by the amount of diverted irrigation water, varied from 61% to 73%, but project efficiency did not increase as the amount of cropland that was sprinkler irrigated increased from 46% in 2006 to 59% in 2016. The only significant trends indicating that increasing sprinkler irrigation impacted the water balances were increasing irrigation project efficiency in July and increasing irrigation return flow during the irrigation season. Farmers may be applying less irrigation water with sprinkler irrigation compared to furrow irrigation, which could have caused return flow to increase since irrigation diversions did not change with the supply-based water allocation. Irrigation scheduling based on soil moisture measurement or daily ET would help irrigation application match crop water needs on individual fields. For the entire irrigation project, irrigation efficiency could improve if irrigation diversions into the watershed could be adjusted to more closely match ET in the spring and fall, which may require structural changes to the canal system and policy changes for the Snake River reservoir system.