2009•Journal of Suzhou University of Science and TechnologyRequires access

A Study of Four Ancient Quoting Methods

SU Xiao-wei

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

When ancient scholars quoted,they sometimes put words from different articles(volumes or chapters) in same book or section of yue in his book.There are lots of problems in abridged quotations in ancient books,some of which are rather serious.When ancient scholars claimed that they quoted something within an unknown author,it was not necessarily case that he could not locate author of text.When ancient scholars said the words are unique and are not found in any of today's books,it may just reveal fact that words are not exactly same as original.The six-thousand-character-long Chen Zheng Shi Shu by Ban Gu is actually such a case,an article padded up from many quotationsfrom many Shu(Memorandum to Emperor) by Jia Yi while Ban Gu was writing The Biography of Jia Yi.A study of how our ancient scholars quoted while writing is still of great significance for us in conducting research work.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

When ancient scholars quoted,they sometimes put words from different articles(volumes or chapters) in same book or section of yue in his book.There are lots of problems in abridged quotations in ancient books,some of which are rather serious.When ancient scholars claimed that they quoted something within an unknown author,it was not necessarily case that he could not locate author of text.When ancient scholars said the words are unique and are not found in any of today's books,it may just reveal fact that words are not exactly same as original.The six-thousand-character-long Chen Zheng Shi Shu by Ban Gu is actually such a case,an article padded up from many quotationsfrom many Shu(Memorandum to Emperor) by Jia Yi while Ban Gu was writing The Biography of Jia Yi.A study of how our ancient scholars quoted while writing is still of great significance for us in conducting research work.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

When ancient scholars quoted,they sometimes put words from different articles(volumes or chapters) in same book or section of yue in his book.There are lots of problems in abridged quotations in ancient books,some of which are rather serious.When ancient scholars claimed that they quoted something within an unknown author,it was not necessarily case that he could not locate author of text.When ancient scholars said the words are unique and are not found in any of today's books,it may just reveal fact that words are not exactly same as original.The six-thousand-character-long Chen Zheng Shi Shu by Ban Gu is actually such a case,an article padded up from many quotationsfrom many Shu(Memorandum to Emperor) by Jia Yi while Ban Gu was writing The Biography of Jia Yi.A study of how our ancient scholars quoted while writing is still of great significance for us in conducting research work.

Key concepts: Emperor, Section (typography), Character (mathematics), Memorandum, Classics, Literature, Biography, History

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
A Study of Four Ancient Quoting Methods — Research Paper | ScholarLens