2022Gachon Law ReviewRequires access

A legal comparative study between the investigatio n of unfair trade practices and the investigation of unfair competition

한국지식재산연구원 부연구위원/건국대학교 겸임교수/법학박사, Mi Rang SHIM, Song Yi Kim

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

Each subparagraph of Article 4, Paragraph 1 of the Unfair Trade I nvestigation Law stipulates the types of unfair trade practices that a re subject to investigation by the Korea Trade Commission(KTC). Th is includes domestic imports and exports of goods that infringe intel lectual property rights. Infringement of intellectual property rights u nder the Unfair Trade Investigation Act includes infringement of pat ent rights, utility model rights, design rights, trademark rights, copyr ights, and trade secrets, but excludes acts of unfair competition und er the Unfair Competition Law. Separate from the investigation under the Unfair Trade Investigatio n Law, the Unfair Competition Law operates an investigation system for unfair competition practices. It is necessary to compare this wit h the unfair trade practice investigation system of KTC and to study the validity and appropriateness of adding unfair competition practices to the scope of intellectual property infringement, which is the subject of investigation under the Unfair Trade Investigation Law. For this purpose, in this study, first, the investigation system unde r the Unfair Trade Investigation Law and the Unfair Competition La w was comparatively analyzed, and the operation status and current status of each system were investigated and analyzed. Next, by exa mining the current state of the unfair trade practice investigation sy stem and related laws in major overseas countries, we looked at cas es in which unfair competition is included in the target of unfair tr ade investigation abroad. Through this, the feasibility of adding unfa ir competition acts under the Unfair Competition Law to the scope of intellectual property infringement under the Unfair Trade Investig ation Law was legally reviewed, and related considerations were pres ented.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Each subparagraph of Article 4, Paragraph 1 of the Unfair Trade I nvestigation Law stipulates the types of unfair trade practices that a re subject to investigation by the Korea Trade Commission(KTC). Th is includes domestic imports and exports of goods that infringe intel lectual property rights. Infringement of intellectual property rights u nder the Unfair Trade Investigation Act includes infringement of pat ent rights, utility model rights, design rights, trademark rights, copyr ights, and trade secrets, but excludes acts of unfair competition und er the Unfair Competition Law. Separate from the investigation under the Unfair Trade Investigatio n Law, the Unfair Competition Law operates an investigation system for unfair competition practices. It is necessary to compare this wit h the unfair trade practice investigation system of KTC and to study the validity and appropriateness of adding unfair competition practices to the scope of intellectual property infringement, which is the subject of investigation under the Unfair Trade Investigation Law. For this purpose, in this study, first, the investigation system unde r the Unfair Trade Investigation Law and the Unfair Competition La w was comparatively analyzed, and the operation status and current status of each system were investigated and analyzed. Next, by exa mining the current state of the unfair trade practice investigation sy stem and related laws in major overseas countries, we looked at cas es in which unfair competition is included in the target of unfair tr ade investigation abroad. Through this, the feasibility of adding unfa ir competition acts under the Unfair Competition Law to the scope of intellectual property infringement under the Unfair Trade Investig ation Law was legally reviewed, and related considerations were pres ented.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Each subparagraph of Article 4, Paragraph 1 of the Unfair Trade I nvestigation Law stipulates the types of unfair trade practices that a re subject to investigation by the Korea Trade Commission(KTC). Th is includes domestic imports and exports of goods that infringe intel lectual property rights. Infringement of intellectual property rights u nder the Unfair Trade Investigation Act includes infringement of pat ent rights, utility model rights, design rights, trademark rights, copyr ights, and trade secrets, but excludes acts of unfair competition und er the Unfair Competition Law. Separate from the investigation under the Unfair Trade Investigatio n Law, the Unfair Competition Law operates an investigation system for unfair competition practices. It is necessary to compare this wit h the unfair trade practice investigation system of KTC and to study the validity and appropriateness of adding unfair competition practices to the scope of intellectual property infringement, which is the subject of investigation under the Unfair Trade Investigation Law. For this purpose, in this study, first, the investigation system unde r the Unfair Trade Investigation Law and the Unfair Competition La w was comparatively analyzed, and the operation status and current status of each system were investigated and analyzed. Next, by exa mining the current state of the unfair trade practice investigation sy stem and related laws in major overseas countries, we looked at cas es in which unfair competition is included in the target of unfair tr ade investigation abroad. Through this, the feasibility of adding unfa ir competition acts under the Unfair Competition Law to the scope of intellectual property infringement under the Unfair Trade Investig ation Law was legally reviewed, and related considerations were pres ented.

Key concepts: Unfair competition, Intellectual property, Trademark, Competition (biology), Competition law, Business, Comparative advertising, International trade

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
A legal comparative study between the investigatio n of unfair trade practices and the investigation of unfair competition — Research Paper | ScholarLens