2005•Journal of Literature,history and PhilosophyRequires access

Historical Investigation of the Opinion of “People’s Advocacy of Red in the Zhou Dynasty”

Xin‐Sheng Hu

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

The opinion of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”offered by the confucian in the Warring States Period is a hypothesis founded by means of exaggerating the meaning of individual facts like people’s habits of advocating red immolations in the Zhou Dynasty. The opinion is hard to establish for it is contradict to the historical facts that white flags and black formal attires advocated in the Western Zhou and the Spring and Autumn Period. Confucian’s argument of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”is very farfetched at first and supplementary explanations given by scholars especially Dong Zhong-shu in the Qin-Han Period are the results that they ignored historical facts and deduced randomly. Totally speaking, the opinion of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”is not much valuable for us to study ritual system of Zhou Dynasty as references. If we readily believe it and infer relevant cultural phenomenons of Zhou Dynasty according to it, mistaken conclusions will be reached easily.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The opinion of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”offered by the confucian in the Warring States Period is a hypothesis founded by means of exaggerating the meaning of individual facts like people’s habits of advocating red immolations in the Zhou Dynasty. The opinion is hard to establish for it is contradict to the historical facts that white flags and black formal attires advocated in the Western Zhou and the Spring and Autumn Period. Confucian’s argument of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”is very farfetched at first and supplementary explanations given by scholars especially Dong Zhong-shu in the Qin-Han Period are the results that they ignored historical facts and deduced randomly. Totally speaking, the opinion of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”is not much valuable for us to study ritual system of Zhou Dynasty as references. If we readily believe it and infer relevant cultural phenomenons of Zhou Dynasty according to it, mistaken conclusions will be reached easily.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The opinion of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”offered by the confucian in the Warring States Period is a hypothesis founded by means of exaggerating the meaning of individual facts like people’s habits of advocating red immolations in the Zhou Dynasty. The opinion is hard to establish for it is contradict to the historical facts that white flags and black formal attires advocated in the Western Zhou and the Spring and Autumn Period. Confucian’s argument of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”is very farfetched at first and supplementary explanations given by scholars especially Dong Zhong-shu in the Qin-Han Period are the results that they ignored historical facts and deduced randomly. Totally speaking, the opinion of “people’s advocacy of red in the Zhou Dynasty”is not much valuable for us to study ritual system of Zhou Dynasty as references. If we readily believe it and infer relevant cultural phenomenons of Zhou Dynasty according to it, mistaken conclusions will be reached easily.

Key concepts: Western Zhou, Shang dynasty, Period (music), White (mutation), Meaning (existential), History, Argument (complex analysis), Original meaning

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Historical Investigation of the Opinion of “People’s Advocacy of Red in the Zhou Dynasty” — Research Paper | ScholarLens