A Comparative Study of LiQi theory of Zhu Xi’s "Universal Variety" and Feng Youlan s New Confucianism
Zeng Chun-hai
Abstract
Zeng Chun-hai
Abstract
This article aims to conduct a comparative study of the metaphysically four core concepts of Feng Youlan’s New Confucianism, namely, Li, Qi, Dao body, and Completeness, and the corresponding concepts of Zhu Xi’s philosophy. Deeply influenced by AngloAmerican logical analysis approach, Mr Feng considered it as a positive method of metaphysics. In this way he made a brand-new interpretation of the corresponding metaphysic concepts of Zhu Xi, claiming that it is not copying but consecutive research with the attempt to develop a new set of Chinese philosophy of metaphysics. Separated but not split, Zhu Xi's Li and Qi are of organic relation. Zhu Xi’s philosophy something out of nothing described the highest nature of metaphysics of Tai Chi with infinite. Mr Feng’s concepts of Li, Qi, Dao body are all shaped from Noumenon, which are incompatible with Zhu Xi’s organic cosmology. Mr. Feng’s split of reality and the practical (phenomenal world) are not compatible with Zhu Xi’s cosmology of Li residing within Qi. However, his attempt of introducing western neorealism to reconstruct New Confucianism and his research results are greatly contributive to the development Chinese traditional philosophy, providing new horizon, new thinking approach, and new interpretation method.
A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
This article aims to conduct a comparative study of the metaphysically four core concepts of Feng Youlan’s New Confucianism, namely, Li, Qi, Dao body, and Completeness, and the corresponding concepts of Zhu Xi’s philosophy. Deeply influenced by AngloAmerican logical analysis approach, Mr Feng considered it as a positive method of metaphysics. In this way he made a brand-new interpretation of the corresponding metaphysic concepts of Zhu Xi, claiming that it is not copying but consecutive research with the attempt to develop a new set of Chinese philosophy of metaphysics. Separated but not split, Zhu Xi's Li and Qi are of organic relation. Zhu Xi’s philosophy something out of nothing described the highest nature of metaphysics of Tai Chi with infinite. Mr Feng’s concepts of Li, Qi, Dao body are all shaped from Noumenon, which are incompatible with Zhu Xi’s organic cosmology. Mr. Feng’s split of reality and the practical (phenomenal world) are not compatible with Zhu Xi’s cosmology of Li residing within Qi. However, his attempt of introducing western neorealism to reconstruct New Confucianism and his research results are greatly contributive to the development Chinese traditional philosophy, providing new horizon, new thinking approach, and new interpretation method.
Key concepts: Philosophy, Metaphysics, Epistemology, Interpretation (philosophy), Noumenon, Chinese philosophy, Nothing, Paraphrase