2014•Zhongguo shiyan fangjixue zazhiRequires access

Guipi Decoction for Treating 30 Cases of Heart-spleen Deficiency Depression

Zhu Chenju

Open publisher page 1 citations

Abstract

Objective: To investigate the therapeutic effect of Guipi decoction compared with Fluoxetine for depression patients with Heart-spleen deficiency. Method: Sixty cases of patients were randomly divided into Guipi decoction group and the Fluoxetine group with 30 cases in each group. Patients were given with Fluoxetine( 20 mg,once a day) in the Fluoxetine group and Guipi decoction was given( half of one decoction,twice a day)in the treatment group. The treatment course was 6 weeks. Hamilton rating scale for depression( HAMD) and traditional chinese medicine( TCM) symptoms scale were measured at week 1,2,4,and 6 after the treatment,and the effective rate was assessed according to HAMD and TCM symptoms scale to evaluate therapeutic effects.Adverse reactions were recorded. Result: Both of the effective rates of HAMD and TCM symptoms increased in two groups along with treatment time. After the first week of treatment,the total effective rate of HAMD in Guipi group( 3. 33%) was higher than that in the Fluoxetine group( 0%)( P 0. 01). However,there was no difference for total effective rate of HAMD between groups after 2,4,or 6 weeks of treatment. The total effective rate of TCM symptoms in Guipi group were 10% and 53. 33% after first and second week of treatment respectively,which were significantly higher( P 0. 01) than that in the Fluoxetine group( 3. 33% and 16. 67%). But no difference was found for effective rate of TCM symptoms between groups after 4 or 6 weeks of treatment. Furthermore,no adverse event was found in Guipi decoction group,while 1 case was dropped out after one week of treatment because of diarrhea in the Fluoxetine group,thus indicated the adverse reaction rate was 3. 33% in the Fluoxetine group( P 0. 01). Conclusion: Compared to Fluoxetine,Guipi decoction has similar effect on improving HAMD scores and TCM symptoms for depression patients with Heart-spleen deficiency,but it has fewer adverse reactions and faster onset of action. In conclusion,Guipi decoction is safe and effective for Heart-spleen deficiency depression.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Objective: To investigate the therapeutic effect of Guipi decoction compared with Fluoxetine for depression patients with Heart-spleen deficiency. Method: Sixty cases of patients were randomly divided into Guipi decoction group and the Fluoxetine group with 30 cases in each group. Patients were given with Fluoxetine( 20 mg,once a day) in the Fluoxetine group and Guipi decoction was given( half of one decoction,twice a day)in the treatment group. The treatment course was 6 weeks. Hamilton rating scale for depression( HAMD) and traditional chinese medicine( TCM) symptoms scale were measured at week 1,2,4,and 6 after the treatment,and the effective rate was assessed according to HAMD and TCM symptoms scale to evaluate therapeutic effects.Adverse reactions were recorded. Result: Both of the effective rates of HAMD and TCM symptoms increased in two groups along with treatment time. After the first week of treatment,the total effective rate of HAMD in Guipi group( 3. 33%) was higher than that in the Fluoxetine group( 0%)( P 0. 01). However,there was no difference for total effective rate of HAMD between groups after 2,4,or 6 weeks of treatment. The total effective rate of TCM symptoms in Guipi group were 10% and 53. 33% after first and second week of treatment respectively,which were significantly higher( P 0. 01) than that in the Fluoxetine group( 3. 33% and 16. 67%). But no difference was found for effective rate of TCM symptoms between groups after 4 or 6 weeks of treatment. Furthermore,no adverse event was found in Guipi decoction group,while 1 case was dropped out after one week of treatment because of diarrhea in the Fluoxetine group,thus indicated the adverse reaction rate was 3. 33% in the Fluoxetine group( P 0. 01). Conclusion: Compared to Fluoxetine,Guipi decoction has similar effect on improving HAMD scores and TCM symptoms for depression patients with Heart-spleen deficiency,but it has fewer adverse reactions and faster onset of action. In conclusion,Guipi decoction is safe and effective for Heart-spleen deficiency depression.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 1 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Objective: To investigate the therapeutic effect of Guipi decoction compared with Fluoxetine for depression patients with Heart-spleen deficiency. Method: Sixty cases of patients were randomly divided into Guipi decoction group and the Fluoxetine group with 30 cases in each group. Patients were given with Fluoxetine( 20 mg,once a day) in the Fluoxetine group and Guipi decoction was given( half of one decoction,twice a day)in the treatment group. The treatment course was 6 weeks. Hamilton rating scale for depression( HAMD) and traditional chinese medicine( TCM) symptoms scale were measured at week 1,2,4,and 6 after the treatment,and the effective rate was assessed according to HAMD and TCM symptoms scale to evaluate therapeutic effects.Adverse reactions were recorded. Result: Both of the effective rates of HAMD and TCM symptoms increased in two groups along with treatment time. After the first week of treatment,the total effective rate of HAMD in Guipi group( 3. 33%) was higher than that in the Fluoxetine group( 0%)( P 0. 01). However,there was no difference for total effective rate of HAMD between groups after 2,4,or 6 weeks of treatment. The total effective rate of TCM symptoms in Guipi group were 10% and 53. 33% after first and second week of treatment respectively,which were significantly higher( P 0. 01) than that in the Fluoxetine group( 3. 33% and 16. 67%). But no difference was found for effective rate of TCM symptoms between groups after 4 or 6 weeks of treatment. Furthermore,no adverse event was found in Guipi decoction group,while 1 case was dropped out after one week of treatment because of diarrhea in the Fluoxetine group,thus indicated the adverse reaction rate was 3. 33% in the Fluoxetine group( P 0. 01). Conclusion: Compared to Fluoxetine,Guipi decoction has similar effect on improving HAMD scores and TCM symptoms for depression patients with Heart-spleen deficiency,but it has fewer adverse reactions and faster onset of action. In conclusion,Guipi decoction is safe and effective for Heart-spleen deficiency depression.

Key concepts: Hamd, Decoction, Fluoxetine, Medicine, Therapeutic effect, Depression (economics), Adverse effect, Internal medicine

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Guipi Decoction for Treating 30 Cases of Heart-spleen Deficiency Depression — Research Paper | ScholarLens