Judicialization of Health: The Brazilian case and a bioethical review
Diego Hermínio Stefanutto Falavinha, Patrícia Borba Marchetto, Hélio Veiga
Abstract
Open-access reader
Diego Hermínio Stefanutto Falavinha, Patrícia Borba Marchetto, Hélio Veiga
Abstract
Open-access reader
Trabalho enviado em 14 de dezembro de 2015. Aceito em 05 de março de 2016. DOI: 10.12957/rqi.2016.20085 Abstract The Judiciary has been used by Brazilian society to seek for the concretion of rights to health through bringing actions in order to force the State to grant drugs, surgeries and other services, creating the concept of Health judicialization, which is an expression derived from the concept of judicialization of Politics, gaining significance in the Brazilian territory. Unfortunately, as will be seen in the next sections, the legalization of Health has taken negative proportions focusing critics on the intervention of the Judiciary in Health and Politics. Nonetheless, the excessive and disorderly legalization of Health do not have their reasons only in poor performance of the Judiciary, but find their genesis in the governmental inefficiency, corruption and market influences. Thereby, the aim of this article is to instigate that the issue of legalization of Health in the Brazilian case is complex, not being enough the occasional interventions in the Judiciary, but a set/group of actions to measure the real dilemmas/quandaries and argue/fight/work towards effective actions to solve it through the balanced performance of all actors, governmental and social involved. Keywords : Judicialization of politics; Judicialization of health; constitutional law; bioethical
OpenAlex reports 5 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Trabalho enviado em 14 de dezembro de 2015. Aceito em 05 de março de 2016. DOI: 10.12957/rqi.2016.20085 Abstract The Judiciary has been used by Brazilian society to seek for the concretion of rights to health through bringing actions in order to force the State to grant drugs, surgeries and other services, creating the concept of Health judicialization, which is an expression derived from the concept of judicialization of Politics, gaining significance in the Brazilian territory. Unfortunately, as will be seen in the next sections, the legalization of Health has taken negative proportions focusing critics on the intervention of the Judiciary in Health and Politics. Nonetheless, the excessive and disorderly legalization of Health do not have their reasons only in poor performance of the Judiciary, but find their genesis in the governmental inefficiency, corruption and market influences. Thereby, the aim of this article is to instigate that the issue of legalization of Health in the Brazilian case is complex, not being enough the occasional interventions in the Judiciary, but a set/group of actions to measure the real dilemmas/quandaries and argue/fight/work towards effective actions to solve it through the balanced performance of all actors, governmental and social involved. Keywords : Judicialization of politics; Judicialization of health; constitutional law; bioethical
Key concepts: Legalization, Right to health, Bioethics, Politics, Political science, Inefficiency, Intervention (counseling), Law