2003International Review for the Sociology of SportRequires access

Race and Penalized Sports Behaviors

Herbert D. Simons

Open publisher page 34 citations

Abstract

Abstract There are a number of verbal and non-verbal behaviors exhibited by football and basket-ball players, such as trash talking, taunting, celebrating, dancing, etc. that are penalized and heavily criticized by the athletic officials, coaches, the media and fans. The amount of attention these behaviors receive seems out of proportion to their importance, since they provide little if any com-petitive advantage and seem to be only peripherally related to the actual competition. It is argued that the undue attention these behaviors receive is racially motivated in that African Americans are to an overwhelming degree responsible for the sanctioned behaviors. These behaviors are a reflection of urban African American cultural norms, which conflict with white mainstream norms. The sanctions represent white male mainstream society’s response to the threat to white masculinity represented by black athletic superiority and by African American athletes ’ assertion of the right to define the meaning of their own behavior. In this contested terrain African Americans are resisting white male hegemony and asserting their manhood and cultural identity. Key words • Culture • hegemony • penalties • race • sports A white man wants to win first and look good second. A black man wants to look good first and win second. (Conversation between Woody Harrelson and Wesley Snipes in the film

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Abstract There are a number of verbal and non-verbal behaviors exhibited by football and basket-ball players, such as trash talking, taunting, celebrating, dancing, etc. that are penalized and heavily criticized by the athletic officials, coaches, the media and fans. The amount of attention these behaviors receive seems out of proportion to their importance, since they provide little if any com-petitive advantage and seem to be only peripherally related to the actual competition. It is argued that the undue attention these behaviors receive is racially motivated in that African Americans are to an overwhelming degree responsible for the sanctioned behaviors. These behaviors are a reflection of urban African American cultural norms, which conflict with white mainstream norms. The sanctions represent white male mainstream society’s response to the threat to white masculinity represented by black athletic superiority and by African American athletes ’ assertion of the right to define the meaning of their own behavior. In this contested terrain African Americans are resisting white male hegemony and asserting their manhood and cultural identity. Key words • Culture • hegemony • penalties • race • sports A white man wants to win first and look good second. A black man wants to look good first and win second. (Conversation between Woody Harrelson and Wesley Snipes in the film

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 34 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Abstract There are a number of verbal and non-verbal behaviors exhibited by football and basket-ball players, such as trash talking, taunting, celebrating, dancing, etc. that are penalized and heavily criticized by the athletic officials, coaches, the media and fans. The amount of attention these behaviors receive seems out of proportion to their importance, since they provide little if any com-petitive advantage and seem to be only peripherally related to the actual competition. It is argued that the undue attention these behaviors receive is racially motivated in that African Americans are to an overwhelming degree responsible for the sanctioned behaviors. These behaviors are a reflection of urban African American cultural norms, which conflict with white mainstream norms. The sanctions represent white male mainstream society’s response to the threat to white masculinity represented by black athletic superiority and by African American athletes ’ assertion of the right to define the meaning of their own behavior. In this contested terrain African Americans are resisting white male hegemony and asserting their manhood and cultural identity. Key words • Culture • hegemony • penalties • race • sports A white man wants to win first and look good second. A black man wants to look good first and win second. (Conversation between Woody Harrelson and Wesley Snipes in the film

Key concepts: Mainstream, White (mutation), Basketball, Race (biology), Psychology, Social psychology, Masculinity, Athletes

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Race and Penalized Sports Behaviors — Research Paper | ScholarLens