Clinical Evaluation of Guided Tissue Regeneration in the Treatment of Maxillary Class II Molar Furcation Invasions

This investigation assessed and compared the clinical efficacy of combined open flap debridement/occlusive membrane therapy versus open flap debridement therapy alone, in the treatment of maxillary periodontal furcation defects. Seventeen patients presenting with advanced adult periodontitis, including at least one pair of Class II maxillary furcal defects, comprised the study group. Following completion of a hygienic phase of treatment, measurements were made with calibrated periodontal probes to determine soft tissue recession, probing pocket depths, and attachment levels. Each pair of furcation defects was surgically exposed and hard tissue measurements obtained. Defects were treated with either open flap debridement and a polytetrafluoroethylene periodontal membrane or open flap debridement alone. Membranes were removed at 4 to 6 weeks. Six months postsurgery, soft tissue measurements were repeated and all sites were surgically re-entered to obtain hard tissue measurements. No statistically significant differences were found in recession, probing depth reductions, clinical attachment gains, or resorption of alveolar crest height between test and control groups. Results for these parameters were inconsistent and unpredictable. Statistically significant improvements were found, however, in horizontal open probing attachment (HOPA) and vertical open probing attachment (VOPA) between experimental and control sites. The GTR procedure as used in this study likely has limited application as a therapeutic modality for Class II furcations of maxillary molars. Modifications or improvements in the procedure may result in more predictable healing of these lesions.