2024•BMC NursingOpen access

Translation and psychometric properties of the comfort behavioral scale-Persian version

Zhila Tahmasb Zamanian, FatemehSadat SeyedNematollah Roshan, Narges Rahmani

Open full text 3 citations

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Managing pain and the level of sedation of critically ill children admitted to the intensive care unit is a complex process and one of the most basic problems of nurses, which requires the use of an available valid, and reliable scale. The present study aimed to translate the comfort behavioral scale into Persian and check its validity and reliability. METHODS: This methodological research was carried out in the children's hospitals of Tehran Province (Iran) from Nov 2023 to Apr 2024. After forward and backward translation, face validity was performed qualitatively and quantitatively. Then, qualitative content validity was checked and the content validity ratio and content validity index were measured. The discriminant validity method was used to determine construct validity, and the nurse interpretation sedation scale and nurse report pain scale were used to check the criterion validity. The concordance correlation coefficient method was used to determine reliability. RESULTS: In quantitative face validity, all 30 items received an impact score of more than 1.5. In qualitative content validity, some words were replaced with more concrete words. In the content validity ratio, considering the minimum value of 0.62 for 10 experts, none of the items were excluded. The content validity index for all items was higher than 0.8 and S-CVI/Ave for the whole scale was 0.96. There was a significant difference between the pain score in the painful state (24.87 ± 2.5) and the resting state (20.9714 ± 2.4) (P = 0.000). The correlation between Comfort and criterion instruments (NISS and NRS) in a resting state and during a painful procedure was positively significant (P < 0.05). The kappa agreement coefficient showed values higher than 0.4 and reliability was confirmed. CONCLUSIONS: The Persian version of the COMFORT behavioral scale has good validity and reliability and can be used as a suitable tool for pain management of hospitalized children with a low level of consciousness and lack of verbal communication. The use of this tool not only helps the clinical, educational, and research process but also leads to an increase in the quality of care and satisfaction of the child and her parents in Iranian hospitals.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

BACKGROUND: Managing pain and the level of sedation of critically ill children admitted to the intensive care unit is a complex process and one of the most basic problems of nurses, which requires the use of an available valid, and reliable scale. The present study aimed to translate the comfort behavioral scale into Persian and check its validity and reliability. METHODS: This methodological research was carried out in the children's hospitals of Tehran Province (Iran) from Nov 2023 to Apr 2024. After forward and backward translation, face validity was performed qualitatively and quantitatively. Then, qualitative content validity was checked and the content validity ratio and content validity index were measured. The discriminant validity method was used to determine construct validity, and the nurse interpretation sedation scale and nurse report pain scale were used to check the criterion validity. The concordance correlation coefficient method was used to determine reliability. RESULTS: In quantitative face validity, all 30 items received an impact score of more than 1.5. In qualitative content validity, some words were replaced with more concrete words. In the content validity ratio, considering the minimum value of 0.62 for 10 experts, none of the items were excluded. The content validity index for all items was higher than 0.8 and S-CVI/Ave for the whole scale was 0.96. There was a significant difference between the pain score in the painful state (24.87 ± 2.5) and the resting state (20.9714 ± 2.4) (P = 0.000). The correlation between Comfort and criterion instruments (NISS and NRS) in a resting state and during a painful procedure was positively significant (P < 0.05). The kappa agreement coefficient showed values higher than 0.4 and reliability was confirmed. CONCLUSIONS: The Persian version of the COMFORT behavioral scale has good validity and reliability and can be used as a suitable tool for pain management of hospitalized children with a low level of consciousness and lack of verbal communication. The use of this tool not only helps the clinical, educational, and research process but also leads to an increase in the quality of care and satisfaction of the child and her parents in Iranian hospitals.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 3 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

BACKGROUND: Managing pain and the level of sedation of critically ill children admitted to the intensive care unit is a complex process and one of the most basic problems of nurses, which requires the use of an available valid, and reliable scale. The present study aimed to translate the comfort behavioral scale into Persian and check its validity and reliability. METHODS: This methodological research was carried out in the children's hospitals of Tehran Province (Iran) from Nov 2023 to Apr 2024. After forward and backward translation, face validity was performed qualitatively and quantitatively. Then, qualitative content validity was checked and the content validity ratio and content validity index were measured. The discriminant validity method was used to determine construct validity, and the nurse interpretation sedation scale and nurse report pain scale were used to check the criterion validity. The concordance correlation coefficient method was used to determine reliability. RESULTS: In quantitative face validity, all 30 items received an impact score of more than 1.5. In qualitative content validity, some words were replaced with more concrete words. In the content validity ratio, considering the minimum value of 0.62 for 10 experts, none of the items were excluded. The content validity index for all items was higher than 0.8 and S-CVI/Ave for the whole scale was 0.96. There was a significant difference between the pain score in the painful state (24.87 ± 2.5) and the resting state (20.9714 ± 2.4) (P = 0.000). The correlation between Comfort and criterion instruments (NISS and NRS) in a resting state and during a painful procedure was positively significant (P < 0.05). The kappa agreement coefficient showed values higher than 0.4 and reliability was confirmed. CONCLUSIONS: The Persian version of the COMFORT behavioral scale has good validity and reliability and can be used as a suitable tool for pain management of hospitalized children with a low level of consciousness and lack of verbal communication. The use of this tool not only helps the clinical, educational, and research process but also leads to an increase in the quality of care and satisfaction of the child and her parents in Iranian hospitals.

Key concepts: Content validity, Face validity, Construct validity, Validity, Discriminant validity, Criterion validity, Scale (ratio), Pain scale

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Translation and psychometric properties of the comfort behavioral scale-Persian version — Research Paper | ScholarLens