2023•Islamic Sciences JournalOpen access

The saying of Bukhari (He disagrees with his hadith) A critical study in his book The Middle History

Ibrahim Mohammed, Aboothar Mohammed

Open full text 0 citations

Abstract

Al-Bukhari gives several words to the narrators in his book Al-Tarikh Al-Awsat, including the word: (he contradicts in his hadith), that is, in his hadith he contradicts hafez, and the contradiction among the narrators is no more than two issues. Either the narrator is weak or trustworthy, and if he is weak and contradicts trustworthy or Hafiz, then his hadith is objectionable, and if he is trustworthy and disagreed with the trustworthy, or who is more trustworthy than him, then his hadith is odd. Al-Bukhari has given this word to seven narrators. The current study shows that all of them are poor and they have contradicted the more trustworthy hafiz.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Al-Bukhari gives several words to the narrators in his book Al-Tarikh Al-Awsat, including the word: (he contradicts in his hadith), that is, in his hadith he contradicts hafez, and the contradiction among the narrators is no more than two issues. Either the narrator is weak or trustworthy, and if he is weak and contradicts trustworthy or Hafiz, then his hadith is objectionable, and if he is trustworthy and disagreed with the trustworthy, or who is more trustworthy than him, then his hadith is odd. Al-Bukhari has given this word to seven narrators. The current study shows that all of them are poor and they have contradicted the more trustworthy hafiz.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Al-Bukhari gives several words to the narrators in his book Al-Tarikh Al-Awsat, including the word: (he contradicts in his hadith), that is, in his hadith he contradicts hafez, and the contradiction among the narrators is no more than two issues. Either the narrator is weak or trustworthy, and if he is weak and contradicts trustworthy or Hafiz, then his hadith is objectionable, and if he is trustworthy and disagreed with the trustworthy, or who is more trustworthy than him, then his hadith is odd. Al-Bukhari has given this word to seven narrators. The current study shows that all of them are poor and they have contradicted the more trustworthy hafiz.

Key concepts: Trustworthiness, Contradiction, Word (group theory), Philosophy, Literature, Psychology, Linguistics, Art

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
The saying of Bukhari (He disagrees with his hadith) A critical study in his book The Middle History — Research Paper | ScholarLens