Heavy Rare Earth Elements and the Sources of Continental Flood Basalts

Abstract Heavy rare earth elements (HREEs) in mafic and ultramafic volcanic rocks are useful recorders of mantle source processes because their ratios are not easily modified by differentiation. Here we utilize REEBOX PRO, a simulator of adiabatic decompression melting of the mantle, to study the behavior of HREEs in the formation of continental flood basalt (CFB) parental magmas in the mantle. We simulate partial melting of depleted peridotite, pyrolitic peridotite, pyroxenite, and peridotite-pyroxenite mixtures at mantle potential temperatures of 1350–1650°C and lithospheric thicknesses of 50–150 km, and compare the results to natural data. Many large igneous provinces are typified by low-Ti and high-Ti CFBs with contrasting HREE patterns. Our results show that low-Ti CFBs originate mainly from peridotitic sources. Flat mid-ocean ridge basalt-like HREE patterns typical of low-Ti CFBs can be generated beneath thick lithosphere (~100 km), given that mantle potential temperatures are high (>1500°C) and garnet is completely consumed from the source. We thus challenge the common interpretation that flat HREE patterns always indicate shallow sources for CFB parental magmas. High-Ti CFBs require pyroxenite-bearing sources (≥10%). Contrary to a common view, their steep oceanic island basalt-like HREE patterns can be generated beneath quite a thin lithosphere (~50 km), which is due to increased garnet stability in pyroxenite sources. When applied to CFBs of the Karoo large igneous province, the results are compatible with a model where a mantle plume penetrates a progressively thinning Gondwana lithosphere.