2022Journal of Viral HepatitisRequires access

RETRACTED: Infectivity of hepatitis B virus (HBV) surface antigen (HBsAg) positive plasma with undetectable HBV‐DNA: Can HBsAg screening be discontinued in Egyptian blood donors?

Magdy El Ekiaby, Junko Tanaka, Harry van Drimmelen, Jean‐Pierre Allain, Nico Lelie

Open publisher page 9 citations

Abstract

Abstract HBV infectivity data were reviewed and the 50% infectious dose (ID 50 ) was reassessed in different HBsAg positive infection stages enabling modelling of transfusion‐transmitted (TT)‐HBV infection risk if HBsAg donor screening was replaced by individual donation nucleic acid amplification technology (ID‐NAT). Quantitative HBsAg and HBV‐DNA assays were performed against international standards to compare the ratio between potential infectious HBV virions and subviral HBsAg particles in Egyptian HBsAg positive blood donors as well as in Japanese chimpanzee samples of known infectivity. HBV‐DNA load below the quantification limit of detection was estimated against a reference standard by replicate NAT testing ( n = 25). Infectivity of chimpanzee samples collected during ramp‐up and declining viremic phase were tested in a human liver chimeric mice (HLCM) model and compared with published infectivity data from different HBsAg positive infection stages. Lowest estimates of ID 50 in HBsAg positive plasma were 3–6 HBV virions in chimpanzee studies. Infectivity decreased approximately 10–100‐fold in the declining viremic phase using HLCM. In acute‐phase samples, HBV to HBsAg particle ratios varied between 1:10 2 –10 4 but in HBsAg positive blood donors this particle ratio reached 1:10 6 –10 12 when viral load was below 100 HBV‐DNA copies/ml. Modelled TT‐HBV risk of an HBsAg positive/ID‐NAT nonreactive blood transfusion was estimated at 9%–46% for components containing 20–200 ml of plasma assuming an ID 50 of 316 (point estimate between 100 and 1000) virions. In the Egyptian setting, discontinuation of HBsAg donor screening and reliance on ID‐NAT alone seems to be unsafe.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Abstract HBV infectivity data were reviewed and the 50% infectious dose (ID 50 ) was reassessed in different HBsAg positive infection stages enabling modelling of transfusion‐transmitted (TT)‐HBV infection risk if HBsAg donor screening was replaced by individual donation nucleic acid amplification technology (ID‐NAT). Quantitative HBsAg and HBV‐DNA assays were performed against international standards to compare the ratio between potential infectious HBV virions and subviral HBsAg particles in Egyptian HBsAg positive blood donors as well as in Japanese chimpanzee samples of known infectivity. HBV‐DNA load below the quantification limit of detection was estimated against a reference standard by replicate NAT testing ( n = 25). Infectivity of chimpanzee samples collected during ramp‐up and declining viremic phase were tested in a human liver chimeric mice (HLCM) model and compared with published infectivity data from different HBsAg positive infection stages. Lowest estimates of ID 50 in HBsAg positive plasma were 3–6 HBV virions in chimpanzee studies. Infectivity decreased approximately 10–100‐fold in the declining viremic phase using HLCM. In acute‐phase samples, HBV to HBsAg particle ratios varied between 1:10 2 –10 4 but in HBsAg positive blood donors this particle ratio reached 1:10 6 –10 12 when viral load was below 100 HBV‐DNA copies/ml. Modelled TT‐HBV risk of an HBsAg positive/ID‐NAT nonreactive blood transfusion was estimated at 9%–46% for components containing 20–200 ml of plasma assuming an ID 50 of 316 (point estimate between 100 and 1000) virions. In the Egyptian setting, discontinuation of HBsAg donor screening and reliance on ID‐NAT alone seems to be unsafe.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 9 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Abstract HBV infectivity data were reviewed and the 50% infectious dose (ID 50 ) was reassessed in different HBsAg positive infection stages enabling modelling of transfusion‐transmitted (TT)‐HBV infection risk if HBsAg donor screening was replaced by individual donation nucleic acid amplification technology (ID‐NAT). Quantitative HBsAg and HBV‐DNA assays were performed against international standards to compare the ratio between potential infectious HBV virions and subviral HBsAg particles in Egyptian HBsAg positive blood donors as well as in Japanese chimpanzee samples of known infectivity. HBV‐DNA load below the quantification limit of detection was estimated against a reference standard by replicate NAT testing ( n = 25). Infectivity of chimpanzee samples collected during ramp‐up and declining viremic phase were tested in a human liver chimeric mice (HLCM) model and compared with published infectivity data from different HBsAg positive infection stages. Lowest estimates of ID 50 in HBsAg positive plasma were 3–6 HBV virions in chimpanzee studies. Infectivity decreased approximately 10–100‐fold in the declining viremic phase using HLCM. In acute‐phase samples, HBV to HBsAg particle ratios varied between 1:10 2 –10 4 but in HBsAg positive blood donors this particle ratio reached 1:10 6 –10 12 when viral load was below 100 HBV‐DNA copies/ml. Modelled TT‐HBV risk of an HBsAg positive/ID‐NAT nonreactive blood transfusion was estimated at 9%–46% for components containing 20–200 ml of plasma assuming an ID 50 of 316 (point estimate between 100 and 1000) virions. In the Egyptian setting, discontinuation of HBsAg donor screening and reliance on ID‐NAT alone seems to be unsafe.

Key concepts: HBsAg, Infectivity, Virology, Hepatitis B virus, Medicine, Hepatitis B, Viral load, Virus

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
RETRACTED: Infectivity of hepatitis B virus (HBV) surface antigen (HBsAg) positive plasma with undetectable HBV‐DNA: Can HBsAg screening be discontinued in Egyptian blood donors? — Research Paper | ScholarLens