Lopez and Federalism
Russell Pannier
Abstract
Open-access reader
Russell Pannier
Abstract
Open-access reader
That in United States v. Lopez' the Supreme Court of the United States modified the law of the Interstate Commerce Clause is obvious. 2 Exactly to what extent the Court modified it is not.But interpretive questions about Lopez aside, others are more fundamental.Should the law of the Interstate Commerce Clause as it existed prior to Lopez have been changed at all?If so, how?This article attempts two things.First, it distinguishes alternative interpretations of Lopez and discusses its implications for the future.Second, it argues that the law of the Interstate Commerce Clause as it existed before Lopez cannot be justified and that, however Lopez itself is best interpreted, it does not take us far enough in the right direction-that of becoming a federalist republic once again.II.
A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
That in United States v. Lopez' the Supreme Court of the United States modified the law of the Interstate Commerce Clause is obvious. 2 Exactly to what extent the Court modified it is not.But interpretive questions about Lopez aside, others are more fundamental.Should the law of the Interstate Commerce Clause as it existed prior to Lopez have been changed at all?If so, how?This article attempts two things.First, it distinguishes alternative interpretations of Lopez and discusses its implications for the future.Second, it argues that the law of the Interstate Commerce Clause as it existed before Lopez cannot be justified and that, however Lopez itself is best interpreted, it does not take us far enough in the right direction-that of becoming a federalist republic once again.II.
Key concepts: Federalism, Law and economics, Political science, Law, Business, Economics, Politics