2021viXraRequires access

Sagnac Experiment – the Factual Analysis

Gocho V. Sharlanov

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

The article starts with a general introduction to the problem in modern physics about the constancy of the speed of light for all frames of reference. In the “General Introduction”, besides presenting the used terms and definitions, the fundament of a real solution about all “unexpected” and “inexplicable” results of the experiments related to the measurement of the velocity of light in the time-spatial region “on the Earth surface” is given. The “Sagnac experiment” was carried out by the French physicist Georges Sagnac in 1913. The presented analysis is based on the classical mechanics and Galilean relativity, which are indisputably valid and legitimate in our local time-spatial region “on the surface of the Earth”. The experiment demonstrates that in relation to a moving system in the stationary space, the speed of the light differs depending on the speed and on the direction of movement of the system in the stationary space. However, the Sagnac experiment is considered as a paradox, because it demonstrates that the speed of light is not the same for all frames of reference – what is not convenient for modern physics, because the special theory of relativity is created on the basis of the claim that “the speed of light is the same for all frames of reference”. As further evidence of the authenticity of the presented analysis, the derivation of the equation which is often used in the rotation analyses is shown. Finally, we can underline that as early as 1913, the Sagnac experiment actually proved that “the speed of light is not the same in relation to all inertial frames of reference”. This was even before the publishing of the general theory of relativity. Is it not surprising that Einstein never commented on this experiment, although certainly knew about its existence… KEY WORDS: special theory of relativity; speed of light postulate; Sagnac experiment; aether; speed of light invariance.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The article starts with a general introduction to the problem in modern physics about the constancy of the speed of light for all frames of reference. In the “General Introduction”, besides presenting the used terms and definitions, the fundament of a real solution about all “unexpected” and “inexplicable” results of the experiments related to the measurement of the velocity of light in the time-spatial region “on the Earth surface” is given. The “Sagnac experiment” was carried out by the French physicist Georges Sagnac in 1913. The presented analysis is based on the classical mechanics and Galilean relativity, which are indisputably valid and legitimate in our local time-spatial region “on the surface of the Earth”. The experiment demonstrates that in relation to a moving system in the stationary space, the speed of the light differs depending on the speed and on the direction of movement of the system in the stationary space. However, the Sagnac experiment is considered as a paradox, because it demonstrates that the speed of light is not the same for all frames of reference – what is not convenient for modern physics, because the special theory of relativity is created on the basis of the claim that “the speed of light is the same for all frames of reference”. As further evidence of the authenticity of the presented analysis, the derivation of the equation which is often used in the rotation analyses is shown. Finally, we can underline that as early as 1913, the Sagnac experiment actually proved that “the speed of light is not the same in relation to all inertial frames of reference”. This was even before the publishing of the general theory of relativity. Is it not surprising that Einstein never commented on this experiment, although certainly knew about its existence… KEY WORDS: special theory of relativity; speed of light postulate; Sagnac experiment; aether; speed of light invariance.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The article starts with a general introduction to the problem in modern physics about the constancy of the speed of light for all frames of reference. In the “General Introduction”, besides presenting the used terms and definitions, the fundament of a real solution about all “unexpected” and “inexplicable” results of the experiments related to the measurement of the velocity of light in the time-spatial region “on the Earth surface” is given. The “Sagnac experiment” was carried out by the French physicist Georges Sagnac in 1913. The presented analysis is based on the classical mechanics and Galilean relativity, which are indisputably valid and legitimate in our local time-spatial region “on the surface of the Earth”. The experiment demonstrates that in relation to a moving system in the stationary space, the speed of the light differs depending on the speed and on the direction of movement of the system in the stationary space. However, the Sagnac experiment is considered as a paradox, because it demonstrates that the speed of light is not the same for all frames of reference – what is not convenient for modern physics, because the special theory of relativity is created on the basis of the claim that “the speed of light is the same for all frames of reference”. As further evidence of the authenticity of the presented analysis, the derivation of the equation which is often used in the rotation analyses is shown. Finally, we can underline that as early as 1913, the Sagnac experiment actually proved that “the speed of light is not the same in relation to all inertial frames of reference”. This was even before the publishing of the general theory of relativity. Is it not surprising that Einstein never commented on this experiment, although certainly knew about its existence… KEY WORDS: special theory of relativity; speed of light postulate; Sagnac experiment; aether; speed of light invariance.

Key concepts: Sagnac effect, Speed of light (cellular automaton), Physics, Reference frame, Special relativity, Rotation (mathematics), Theory of relativity, Classical physics

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Sagnac Experiment – the Factual Analysis — Research Paper | ScholarLens