2021viXraRequires access

A Solution to the Twin Paradox and a New Interpretation of Inertial and Non-Inertial Reference Frames

Henok Tadesse

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

In this paper we propose that the velocity in the Lorentz transformation ( LT ) equations and special relativity can only be instantaneous relative velocity between inertial reference frames. We will see that this interpretation will resolve the twin paradox and lead to a deeper understanding of inertial and non-inertial reference frames. Physicists failed to note that if the travelling twin suddenly decelerated from relativistic velocity to low velocity, all space and time coordinates and separations / intervals of events will also change suddenly, retroactively, in such a way as if the travelling twin had always been travelling at that low velocity. When the travelling twin returns to Earth and comes to rest relative to the stationary twin, all ‘memory’ of his/her past relativistic journey will be lost and time intervals of events will also change retroactively as if he/she had always been at rest relative to the stationary twin, as if he had never travelled at relativistic speeds. Only instantaneous velocity is relevant and all motion history of the twin is irrelevant in the Lorentz transformations. Therefore, the problem is symmetrical with respect to both twins. Intuitive and inconsistent application of time dilation (and length contraction), rather than rigorous and consistent application of Lorentz coordinate transformation of events, has caused the creation and persistence of the twin paradox. Lorentz transformation is fundamentally about coordinate transformation of events and time dilation and length contraction are only consequences of LT. The twin paradox is a result of a somehow mixed ( relativistic and classical) views of time.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

In this paper we propose that the velocity in the Lorentz transformation ( LT ) equations and special relativity can only be instantaneous relative velocity between inertial reference frames. We will see that this interpretation will resolve the twin paradox and lead to a deeper understanding of inertial and non-inertial reference frames. Physicists failed to note that if the travelling twin suddenly decelerated from relativistic velocity to low velocity, all space and time coordinates and separations / intervals of events will also change suddenly, retroactively, in such a way as if the travelling twin had always been travelling at that low velocity. When the travelling twin returns to Earth and comes to rest relative to the stationary twin, all ‘memory’ of his/her past relativistic journey will be lost and time intervals of events will also change retroactively as if he/she had always been at rest relative to the stationary twin, as if he had never travelled at relativistic speeds. Only instantaneous velocity is relevant and all motion history of the twin is irrelevant in the Lorentz transformations. Therefore, the problem is symmetrical with respect to both twins. Intuitive and inconsistent application of time dilation (and length contraction), rather than rigorous and consistent application of Lorentz coordinate transformation of events, has caused the creation and persistence of the twin paradox. Lorentz transformation is fundamentally about coordinate transformation of events and time dilation and length contraction are only consequences of LT. The twin paradox is a result of a somehow mixed ( relativistic and classical) views of time.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

In this paper we propose that the velocity in the Lorentz transformation ( LT ) equations and special relativity can only be instantaneous relative velocity between inertial reference frames. We will see that this interpretation will resolve the twin paradox and lead to a deeper understanding of inertial and non-inertial reference frames. Physicists failed to note that if the travelling twin suddenly decelerated from relativistic velocity to low velocity, all space and time coordinates and separations / intervals of events will also change suddenly, retroactively, in such a way as if the travelling twin had always been travelling at that low velocity. When the travelling twin returns to Earth and comes to rest relative to the stationary twin, all ‘memory’ of his/her past relativistic journey will be lost and time intervals of events will also change retroactively as if he/she had always been at rest relative to the stationary twin, as if he had never travelled at relativistic speeds. Only instantaneous velocity is relevant and all motion history of the twin is irrelevant in the Lorentz transformations. Therefore, the problem is symmetrical with respect to both twins. Intuitive and inconsistent application of time dilation (and length contraction), rather than rigorous and consistent application of Lorentz coordinate transformation of events, has caused the creation and persistence of the twin paradox. Lorentz transformation is fundamentally about coordinate transformation of events and time dilation and length contraction are only consequences of LT. The twin paradox is a result of a somehow mixed ( relativistic and classical) views of time.

Key concepts: Twin paradox, Inertial frame of reference, Time dilation, Length contraction, Lorentz transformation, Classical mechanics, Physics, Reference frame

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
A Solution to the Twin Paradox and a New Interpretation of Inertial and Non-Inertial Reference Frames — Research Paper | ScholarLens