The Costs of Worker Displacement
Daniel S. Hamermesh
Abstract
Open-access reader
Daniel S. Hamermesh
Abstract
Open-access reader
This study defines the nature of worker displacement and develops a mechanism for inferring the amount of losses caused by displacement in a way that is tied to economic theory.Data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics are first used to identify the characteristics of displaced workers.After a demonstration that usual methods of evaluating workers' losses cannot provide correct measures of the cost to society, a game-theoretic model determining the amount of firm-specific investment in workers is developed.As workers' and firms' horizons decrease, such investment will be reduced; this will be exhibited in a flattening of the wage-tenure profile as the date of displacement approaches.Examination of the profile thus provides a test whether firms and workers have good information about impending displacement.Using the P5W data for workers displaced between 197? and 1981, the study shows there is no significant flattening of the wage-tenure profile in the entire sample.(However, some flattening does occur among unionized workers, and also among workers who are laid-off permanently from a plant that remains open.)This suggests that workers are surprised by displacement, for they continue investing in firm-specific human capital up to the time of displacement.The present value of the worker's share of the lost returns on this investment is around $7000 (1980 dollars) under intermediate assumptions about the real rate of discount, depreciation on such investment and the effect of tenure on the rate of voluntary separation.
OpenAlex reports 14 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
This study defines the nature of worker displacement and develops a mechanism for inferring the amount of losses caused by displacement in a way that is tied to economic theory.Data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics are first used to identify the characteristics of displaced workers.After a demonstration that usual methods of evaluating workers' losses cannot provide correct measures of the cost to society, a game-theoretic model determining the amount of firm-specific investment in workers is developed.As workers' and firms' horizons decrease, such investment will be reduced; this will be exhibited in a flattening of the wage-tenure profile as the date of displacement approaches.Examination of the profile thus provides a test whether firms and workers have good information about impending displacement.Using the P5W data for workers displaced between 197? and 1981, the study shows there is no significant flattening of the wage-tenure profile in the entire sample.(However, some flattening does occur among unionized workers, and also among workers who are laid-off permanently from a plant that remains open.)This suggests that workers are surprised by displacement, for they continue investing in firm-specific human capital up to the time of displacement.The present value of the worker's share of the lost returns on this investment is around $7000 (1980 dollars) under intermediate assumptions about the real rate of discount, depreciation on such investment and the effect of tenure on the rate of voluntary separation.
Key concepts: Displacement (psychology), Business, Psychology, Psychotherapist