2018PubMedRequires access

[The physician and prevention: by all means deliberate extensively, but do make a decision].

Willem JJ Assendelft

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

The role of prevention in medical care has recently been described and discussed in various strategy reports by Dutch medical professional organisations. However, there are still doubts concerning the effectiveness and feasibility of practising preventive medicine. Both inconclusive evidence on its effectiveness, including on long-term outcomes of preventive medicine interventions, and studies showing positive results have been published. In general, more intensive approaches towards lifestyle change are more effective. Regarding disease-related prevention intervention, various authors stress that this is undoubtedly a task reserved for physicians. Their degree of responsibility and input is less clear when it comes to indicated and selective prevention. Nonetheless, for these latter types of prevention there seems to be a role reserved for the physician, given the increase in lifestyle-related chronic diseases and the prevalence of social class related health inequity. Here, the author argues that physicians are ideally positioned as advisor and motivator, especially towards more vulnerable patients. Aftercare can be organised in partnership with other providers. To take an active role in prevention still needs 'guts', and physicians are challenged to take a position in this.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The role of prevention in medical care has recently been described and discussed in various strategy reports by Dutch medical professional organisations. However, there are still doubts concerning the effectiveness and feasibility of practising preventive medicine. Both inconclusive evidence on its effectiveness, including on long-term outcomes of preventive medicine interventions, and studies showing positive results have been published. In general, more intensive approaches towards lifestyle change are more effective. Regarding disease-related prevention intervention, various authors stress that this is undoubtedly a task reserved for physicians. Their degree of responsibility and input is less clear when it comes to indicated and selective prevention. Nonetheless, for these latter types of prevention there seems to be a role reserved for the physician, given the increase in lifestyle-related chronic diseases and the prevalence of social class related health inequity. Here, the author argues that physicians are ideally positioned as advisor and motivator, especially towards more vulnerable patients. Aftercare can be organised in partnership with other providers. To take an active role in prevention still needs 'guts', and physicians are challenged to take a position in this.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The role of prevention in medical care has recently been described and discussed in various strategy reports by Dutch medical professional organisations. However, there are still doubts concerning the effectiveness and feasibility of practising preventive medicine. Both inconclusive evidence on its effectiveness, including on long-term outcomes of preventive medicine interventions, and studies showing positive results have been published. In general, more intensive approaches towards lifestyle change are more effective. Regarding disease-related prevention intervention, various authors stress that this is undoubtedly a task reserved for physicians. Their degree of responsibility and input is less clear when it comes to indicated and selective prevention. Nonetheless, for these latter types of prevention there seems to be a role reserved for the physician, given the increase in lifestyle-related chronic diseases and the prevalence of social class related health inequity. Here, the author argues that physicians are ideally positioned as advisor and motivator, especially towards more vulnerable patients. Aftercare can be organised in partnership with other providers. To take an active role in prevention still needs 'guts', and physicians are challenged to take a position in this.

Key concepts: Medicine, Psychological intervention, General partnership, Intervention (counseling), Preventive healthcare, Disease prevention, Family medicine, Nursing

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
[The physician and prevention: by all means deliberate extensively, but do make a decision]. — Research Paper | ScholarLens