2008•SSRN Electronic JournalOpen access

"Copyright Contracts, Public Policy and Competition: Can Adhesion Contracts Override Copyright Limits? The Answer Lies within Copyright Law Itself"

Estelle Derclaye

Open full text 0 citations

Abstract

While in case of anti-copying devices, the means to prevent copying (lawful or unlawful) are technical, the same result may be achieved by way of contract, e.g. through shrink-wrap and click-wrap licences. There are two main questions to be addressed: are such contracts valid under contract law and if so, are they nevertheless valid under copyright law? As a matter of fact, copyright contracts overriding limits to copyright can lead to a number of public policy issues, namely if such clauses can be made binding especially to consumers. The question is to what extent the limits of copyright law are principles of public policy that may not be overridden by contractual provisions and thus whether, if at all, copyright limits can be compromised to meet commercial needs.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

While in case of anti-copying devices, the means to prevent copying (lawful or unlawful) are technical, the same result may be achieved by way of contract, e.g. through shrink-wrap and click-wrap licences. There are two main questions to be addressed: are such contracts valid under contract law and if so, are they nevertheless valid under copyright law? As a matter of fact, copyright contracts overriding limits to copyright can lead to a number of public policy issues, namely if such clauses can be made binding especially to consumers. The question is to what extent the limits of copyright law are principles of public policy that may not be overridden by contractual provisions and thus whether, if at all, copyright limits can be compromised to meet commercial needs.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

While in case of anti-copying devices, the means to prevent copying (lawful or unlawful) are technical, the same result may be achieved by way of contract, e.g. through shrink-wrap and click-wrap licences. There are two main questions to be addressed: are such contracts valid under contract law and if so, are they nevertheless valid under copyright law? As a matter of fact, copyright contracts overriding limits to copyright can lead to a number of public policy issues, namely if such clauses can be made binding especially to consumers. The question is to what extent the limits of copyright law are principles of public policy that may not be overridden by contractual provisions and thus whether, if at all, copyright limits can be compromised to meet commercial needs.

Key concepts: Copying, Copyright law, Public domain, Law and economics, Copyright Act, Intellectual property, Business, Fair use

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
"Copyright Contracts, Public Policy and Competition: Can Adhesion Contracts Override Copyright Limits? The Answer Lies within Copyright Law Itself" — Research Paper | ScholarLens