אם . . . ה: A rhetorical question anticipating a negative answer
Rebecca S. Watson
Abstract
Rebecca S. Watson
Abstract
The interrogative sequence אִם . . . הֲ in Biblical Hebrew can be employed in two forms of disjunctive question. The first offers mutually exclusive questions and the second comprises a rhetorical pair. Close examination of the extant examples reveals no difficulty in distinguishing between these two forms and, further, that, when employed to express a rhetorical question, the double rhetorical sequence אִם . . . הֲ anticipates the answer ‘No’. Careful study of a debated example, Jer. 31.20, confirms that a negative answer is implied here, hence the evidence strongly favours this reading in the other contentious passage, Hab. 3.8. Here, triple rhetorical questions introduced by the interrogative particles אִם . . . אִם . . . הֲ are employed in a motivated interrogative sentence, suggesting that a negative answer is therefore expected.
OpenAlex reports 19 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
The interrogative sequence אִם . . . הֲ in Biblical Hebrew can be employed in two forms of disjunctive question. The first offers mutually exclusive questions and the second comprises a rhetorical pair. Close examination of the extant examples reveals no difficulty in distinguishing between these two forms and, further, that, when employed to express a rhetorical question, the double rhetorical sequence אִם . . . הֲ anticipates the answer ‘No’. Careful study of a debated example, Jer. 31.20, confirms that a negative answer is implied here, hence the evidence strongly favours this reading in the other contentious passage, Hab. 3.8. Here, triple rhetorical questions introduced by the interrogative particles אִם . . . אִם . . . הֲ are employed in a motivated interrogative sentence, suggesting that a negative answer is therefore expected.
Key concepts: Interrogative, Rhetorical question, Linguistics, Extant taxon, Sentence, Interrogative word, Reading (process), Philosophy