2019Journal of Applied StatisticsOpen access

Distribution of the C statistic with applications to the sample mean of Poisson data

Massimiliano Bonamente

Open full text 20 citations

Abstract

The C statistic, also known as the Cash statistic, is often used in astronomy for the analysis of low-count Poisson data. The main advantage of this statistic, compared to the more commonly used χ2 statistic, is its applicability without the need to combine data points. This feature has made the C statistic a very useful method to analyze Poisson data that have small (or even null) counts in each resolution element. One of the challenges of the C statistic is that its probability distribution, under the null hypothesis that the data follow a parent model, is not known exactly. This paper presents an effort towards improving our understanding of the C statistic by studying (a) the distribution of C statistic for a fully specified model, (b) the distribution of Cmin resulting from a maximum-likelihood fit to a simple one-parameter constant model, i.e. a model that represents the sample mean of N Poisson measurements, and (c) the distribution of the associated ΔC statistic that is used for parameter estimation. The results confirm the expectation that, in the high-count limit, both C statistic and Cmin have the same mean and variance as a χ2 statistic with same number of degrees of freedom. It is also found that, in the low-count regime, the expectation of the C statistic and Cmin can be substantially lower than for a χ2 distribution. The paper makes use of recent X-ray observations of the astronomical source PG 1116+215 to illustrate the application of the C statistic to Poisson data.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The C statistic, also known as the Cash statistic, is often used in astronomy for the analysis of low-count Poisson data. The main advantage of this statistic, compared to the more commonly used χ2 statistic, is its applicability without the need to combine data points. This feature has made the C statistic a very useful method to analyze Poisson data that have small (or even null) counts in each resolution element. One of the challenges of the C statistic is that its probability distribution, under the null hypothesis that the data follow a parent model, is not known exactly. This paper presents an effort towards improving our understanding of the C statistic by studying (a) the distribution of C statistic for a fully specified model, (b) the distribution of Cmin resulting from a maximum-likelihood fit to a simple one-parameter constant model, i.e. a model that represents the sample mean of N Poisson measurements, and (c) the distribution of the associated ΔC statistic that is used for parameter estimation. The results confirm the expectation that, in the high-count limit, both C statistic and Cmin have the same mean and variance as a χ2 statistic with same number of degrees of freedom. It is also found that, in the low-count regime, the expectation of the C statistic and Cmin can be substantially lower than for a χ2 distribution. The paper makes use of recent X-ray observations of the astronomical source PG 1116+215 to illustrate the application of the C statistic to Poisson data.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 20 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The C statistic, also known as the Cash statistic, is often used in astronomy for the analysis of low-count Poisson data. The main advantage of this statistic, compared to the more commonly used χ2 statistic, is its applicability without the need to combine data points. This feature has made the C statistic a very useful method to analyze Poisson data that have small (or even null) counts in each resolution element. One of the challenges of the C statistic is that its probability distribution, under the null hypothesis that the data follow a parent model, is not known exactly. This paper presents an effort towards improving our understanding of the C statistic by studying (a) the distribution of C statistic for a fully specified model, (b) the distribution of Cmin resulting from a maximum-likelihood fit to a simple one-parameter constant model, i.e. a model that represents the sample mean of N Poisson measurements, and (c) the distribution of the associated ΔC statistic that is used for parameter estimation. The results confirm the expectation that, in the high-count limit, both C statistic and Cmin have the same mean and variance as a χ2 statistic with same number of degrees of freedom. It is also found that, in the low-count regime, the expectation of the C statistic and Cmin can be substantially lower than for a χ2 distribution. The paper makes use of recent X-ray observations of the astronomical source PG 1116+215 to illustrate the application of the C statistic to Poisson data.

Key concepts: PRESS statistic, Ancillary statistic, Statistic, F-test, Poisson distribution, Statistics, Mathematics, Sufficient statistic

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Distribution of the C statistic with applications to the sample mean of Poisson data — Research Paper | ScholarLens