2019•Durham e-Theses (Durham University)Requires access

Virginia Woolf and Ecstasy: Feeling Beside Oneself to Touch the Thing Itself

Angela P. Harris

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

In this thesis, Virginia Woolf’s ecstatic ‘moments of being’ are placed at the heart of a close and contextualized critical reading of her writing. Woolf's three most experimental novels, written in the middle of her career, are the focus of this reading: Mrs Dalloway, To the Lighthouse, and The Waves. Woolf’s writings suggest that embodied feeling - and in particular, ecstatic embodied feeling – is an integral part of how we make meaning. When Woolf’s characters feel the ecstasy of a ‘moment of being’ this marks a profound experience of the ‘other’. By engaging with this experience of otherness in an embodied manner, Woolf’s characters are able to feel and think their way toward an understanding of themselves and/or their world that is wholly new to them. Woolf thereby models for the reader, through her fictional dramatisation of these ecstatic ‘moments of being’, her processes and ethics of making meaning. Each of the three novels is read alongside an ethical motif that Woolf foregrounds in the novel as central to a ‘moment of being’: Jacques Derrida’s arrivant, Emmanuel Levinas’s ‘face’, and Marcel Mauss’s ‘gift’. Woolf’s philosophy and ethics are thereby thrown into relief as against the ethics of these thinkers. But also, by staging a comparison between Woolf’s fiction and these philosophical writings, this thesis probes questions about literary expression and literary criticism. Woolf’s thoughts on what literary form(s) can offer to philosophical and specifically ethical thinking are explored. This thesis is in conversation with scholarly criticism on Woolf that emphasises the phenomenological, ‘ordinary’, immanent, and material, as well as the mystical, epiphanic, and religious aspects of her fiction. The thesis also argues against Woolf critics who characterise Woolf’s ‘moments of being’ as merely symptomatic of madness, trauma, or a deconstructive ‘empty centre’, anomalies of an otherwise rigorously rational mind. Instead it is suggested that the Woolfian moment models how to make meaning well, by combining feeling with thinking in a manner that gives privilege to feeling as an arbiter for making meaning. The anatomy of this process, and its various epistemological and ethical ramifications, form the subject of this thesis.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

In this thesis, Virginia Woolf’s ecstatic ‘moments of being’ are placed at the heart of a close and contextualized critical reading of her writing. Woolf's three most experimental novels, written in the middle of her career, are the focus of this reading: Mrs Dalloway, To the Lighthouse, and The Waves. Woolf’s writings suggest that embodied feeling - and in particular, ecstatic embodied feeling – is an integral part of how we make meaning. When Woolf’s characters feel the ecstasy of a ‘moment of being’ this marks a profound experience of the ‘other’. By engaging with this experience of otherness in an embodied manner, Woolf’s characters are able to feel and think their way toward an understanding of themselves and/or their world that is wholly new to them. Woolf thereby models for the reader, through her fictional dramatisation of these ecstatic ‘moments of being’, her processes and ethics of making meaning. Each of the three novels is read alongside an ethical motif that Woolf foregrounds in the novel as central to a ‘moment of being’: Jacques Derrida’s arrivant, Emmanuel Levinas’s ‘face’, and Marcel Mauss’s ‘gift’. Woolf’s philosophy and ethics are thereby thrown into relief as against the ethics of these thinkers. But also, by staging a comparison between Woolf’s fiction and these philosophical writings, this thesis probes questions about literary expression and literary criticism. Woolf’s thoughts on what literary form(s) can offer to philosophical and specifically ethical thinking are explored. This thesis is in conversation with scholarly criticism on Woolf that emphasises the phenomenological, ‘ordinary’, immanent, and material, as well as the mystical, epiphanic, and religious aspects of her fiction. The thesis also argues against Woolf critics who characterise Woolf’s ‘moments of being’ as merely symptomatic of madness, trauma, or a deconstructive ‘empty centre’, anomalies of an otherwise rigorously rational mind. Instead it is suggested that the Woolfian moment models how to make meaning well, by combining feeling with thinking in a manner that gives privilege to feeling as an arbiter for making meaning. The anatomy of this process, and its various epistemological and ethical ramifications, form the subject of this thesis.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

In this thesis, Virginia Woolf’s ecstatic ‘moments of being’ are placed at the heart of a close and contextualized critical reading of her writing. Woolf's three most experimental novels, written in the middle of her career, are the focus of this reading: Mrs Dalloway, To the Lighthouse, and The Waves. Woolf’s writings suggest that embodied feeling - and in particular, ecstatic embodied feeling – is an integral part of how we make meaning. When Woolf’s characters feel the ecstasy of a ‘moment of being’ this marks a profound experience of the ‘other’. By engaging with this experience of otherness in an embodied manner, Woolf’s characters are able to feel and think their way toward an understanding of themselves and/or their world that is wholly new to them. Woolf thereby models for the reader, through her fictional dramatisation of these ecstatic ‘moments of being’, her processes and ethics of making meaning. Each of the three novels is read alongside an ethical motif that Woolf foregrounds in the novel as central to a ‘moment of being’: Jacques Derrida’s arrivant, Emmanuel Levinas’s ‘face’, and Marcel Mauss’s ‘gift’. Woolf’s philosophy and ethics are thereby thrown into relief as against the ethics of these thinkers. But also, by staging a comparison between Woolf’s fiction and these philosophical writings, this thesis probes questions about literary expression and literary criticism. Woolf’s thoughts on what literary form(s) can offer to philosophical and specifically ethical thinking are explored. This thesis is in conversation with scholarly criticism on Woolf that emphasises the phenomenological, ‘ordinary’, immanent, and material, as well as the mystical, epiphanic, and religious aspects of her fiction. The thesis also argues against Woolf critics who characterise Woolf’s ‘moments of being’ as merely symptomatic of madness, trauma, or a deconstructive ‘empty centre’, anomalies of an otherwise rigorously rational mind. Instead it is suggested that the Woolfian moment models how to make meaning well, by combining feeling with thinking in a manner that gives privilege to feeling as an arbiter for making meaning. The anatomy of this process, and its various epistemological and ethical ramifications, form the subject of this thesis.

Key concepts: Embodied cognition, Feeling, Meaning (existential), Literature, Philosophy, Reading (process), Motif (music), Aesthetics

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Virginia Woolf and Ecstasy: Feeling Beside Oneself to Touch the Thing Itself — Research Paper | ScholarLens