Tissue Doppler imaging in different locations of the mitral annulus: all different or all the same?

BACKGROUND: The assessment of the mitral annulus motion with tissue Doppler imaging is claimed to be an accurate method to quantify global left ventricular systolic and diastolic function. However, it is not yet perfectly defined which site of the annulus must be selected. Familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy of the Portuguese type (FAP) is an hereditary systemic disease in which diastolic dysfunction may occur. AIM: 1--To determine if in FAP patients the mitral annulus motion is independent of the selected site. 2--To compare pulsed wave Doppler parameters with tissue Doppler parameters in the different annular sites. METHODS: Of 24 FAP patients studied, 14 were included. In each patient we performed conventional transmitral pulsed wave Doppler and tissue Doppler in the 4 sites of the mitral annulus and measured the velocities of the rapid filling wave e, of the atrial contraction wave a and calculated e/a ratio. RESULTS: According to the transmitral inflow profile, patients were divided in 2 groups: Group I--normal global diastolic function and Group II--abnormal relaxation. Group I--33% of these patients showed e/a > 1 in the four sites and 67% showed e/a > 1 in at least 1, but not in all the sites. The rate of normal sites per patient was 3.1. Group II--25% of these patients showed e/a < 1 in the 4 sites of the annulus and 75% had e/a < 1 in at least 1, but not in all the sites analysed. The rate of abnormal sites/patient was 3.1. in this group. When conventional and tissue Doppler data were compared (bland and altman) the septal portion of the annulus was the one with the best correlation. CONCLUSIONS: 1--The assessment of the mitral annulus motion with tissue Doppler imaging is dependent on the site selected for study. 2--The septal site was the one that showed the highest correlation and concordance between pulsed wave Doppler and tissue Doppler. 3--The relative number of normal versus abnormal sites was determinant of the transmitral pattern. 4--Tissue Doppler imaging identified: a) among patients until now classified as normal diastolic function, a subgroup of patients with abnormal function in some sites of the annulus and b) among patients with abnormal relaxation, a subgroup with normal diastolic function in some sites of the annulus.