Against the narrative self
Ayesha Rehman
Abstract
Open-access reader
Ayesha Rehman
Abstract
Open-access reader
In my thesis, I argue against the narrative conception of self, the idea that our self is \nnarrative in structure and that we live life as a narrative. First, I differentiate between the \nstrong and weak narrative view of self. I classify Dennett and Bruner’s account as the \nstrong claim, Schechtman and Cavarero’s as the weak narrative claim. Second, I reject \nboth the descriptive and normative narrativity thesis. I question the universality of a \nNarrative outlook. I argue that the artificial constructing of a narrative self is not conducive \nto self-understanding and that our choices of structuring it might be limiting. Last, I defend \nthe non-Narrative conception of self against the common objection that without a selfnarrative \none cannot be held accountable. I discuss Eichmann’s defense in Jerusalem along \nthe way to untangle the link between narrativity and accountability.
OpenAlex reports 1 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
In my thesis, I argue against the narrative conception of self, the idea that our self is \nnarrative in structure and that we live life as a narrative. First, I differentiate between the \nstrong and weak narrative view of self. I classify Dennett and Bruner’s account as the \nstrong claim, Schechtman and Cavarero’s as the weak narrative claim. Second, I reject \nboth the descriptive and normative narrativity thesis. I question the universality of a \nNarrative outlook. I argue that the artificial constructing of a narrative self is not conducive \nto self-understanding and that our choices of structuring it might be limiting. Last, I defend \nthe non-Narrative conception of self against the common objection that without a selfnarrative \none cannot be held accountable. I discuss Eichmann’s defense in Jerusalem along \nthe way to untangle the link between narrativity and accountability.
Key concepts: Narrative, Psychology, Literature, Art