2018•University of Birmingham Institutional Research Archive (University of Birmingham)Requires access

Why do we pay tax? is it because we are good citizens? how tax fits with modern conceptualisations of citizenship

Samantha Leigh Hart

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

Why do we pay tax? If an individual is acting in self-interest, it makes sense to avoid, or evade, as much tax as possible. Rather than exploring why people don't pay tax, this research looks at the reasons why people do pay tax, and asks whether a socio-contractual rights and responsibilities model of citizenship can help explain the tax compliance decision. Through qualitative interviews with the very wealthy, as well as focus group data, this research finds that people. do accept an \nobligation to pay tax as part of the contribution condition of citizenship, but that paying tax is not an essential part of being a good citizen; what is crucial is making a contribution either evidenced by tax, or by alternative means. \nParticipants did not feel low earners were necessarily not fulfilling their civic duties, although it was important they were not making a negative contribution. \nAttitudes towards tax avoidance and tax evasion were also explored; when presented with 'real-life' scenarios, most people were more forgiving of some evasion, dependent on the evader's personal circumstances. Evading tax did not necessarily affect that person's 'good citizen' status, reinforcing the idea that paying tax, while an element of citizenship, is not definitive.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Why do we pay tax? If an individual is acting in self-interest, it makes sense to avoid, or evade, as much tax as possible. Rather than exploring why people don't pay tax, this research looks at the reasons why people do pay tax, and asks whether a socio-contractual rights and responsibilities model of citizenship can help explain the tax compliance decision. Through qualitative interviews with the very wealthy, as well as focus group data, this research finds that people. do accept an \nobligation to pay tax as part of the contribution condition of citizenship, but that paying tax is not an essential part of being a good citizen; what is crucial is making a contribution either evidenced by tax, or by alternative means. \nParticipants did not feel low earners were necessarily not fulfilling their civic duties, although it was important they were not making a negative contribution. \nAttitudes towards tax avoidance and tax evasion were also explored; when presented with 'real-life' scenarios, most people were more forgiving of some evasion, dependent on the evader's personal circumstances. Evading tax did not necessarily affect that person's 'good citizen' status, reinforcing the idea that paying tax, while an element of citizenship, is not definitive.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Why do we pay tax? If an individual is acting in self-interest, it makes sense to avoid, or evade, as much tax as possible. Rather than exploring why people don't pay tax, this research looks at the reasons why people do pay tax, and asks whether a socio-contractual rights and responsibilities model of citizenship can help explain the tax compliance decision. Through qualitative interviews with the very wealthy, as well as focus group data, this research finds that people. do accept an \nobligation to pay tax as part of the contribution condition of citizenship, but that paying tax is not an essential part of being a good citizen; what is crucial is making a contribution either evidenced by tax, or by alternative means. \nParticipants did not feel low earners were necessarily not fulfilling their civic duties, although it was important they were not making a negative contribution. \nAttitudes towards tax avoidance and tax evasion were also explored; when presented with 'real-life' scenarios, most people were more forgiving of some evasion, dependent on the evader's personal circumstances. Evading tax did not necessarily affect that person's 'good citizen' status, reinforcing the idea that paying tax, while an element of citizenship, is not definitive.

Key concepts: Citizenship, Tax avoidance, Obligation, Law and economics, Public economics, Tax reform, Tax credit, Good citizenship

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Why do we pay tax? is it because we are good citizens? how tax fits with modern conceptualisations of citizenship — Research Paper | ScholarLens