Unified Scaling Law for flux pinning in practical superconductors: II. Parameter testing, scaling constants, and the Extrapolative Scaling Expression
J. W. Ekin, N. Cheggour, L.F. Goodrich, Jolene D. Splett, B. Bordini, David H. Richter
Abstract
J. W. Ekin, N. Cheggour, L.F. Goodrich, Jolene D. Splett, B. Bordini, David H. Richter
Abstract
Abstract A scaling study of several thousand Nb 3 Sn critical-current ( I c ) measurements is used to derive the Extrapolative Scaling Expression (ESE), a relation that can quickly and accurately extrapolate limited datasets to obtain full three-dimensional dependences of I c on magnetic field ( B ), temperature ( T ), and mechanical strain ( ε ). The relation has the advantage of being easy to implement, and offers significant savings in sample characterization time and a useful tool for magnet design. Thorough data-based analysis of the general parameterization of the Unified Scaling Law (USL) shows the existence of three universal scaling constants for practical Nb 3 Sn conductors. The study also identifies the scaling parameters that are conductor specific and need to be fitted to each conductor. This investigation includes two new, rare, and very large I c ( B , T , ε ) datasets (each with nearly a thousand I c measurements spanning magnetic fields from 1 to 16 T, temperatures from ∼2.26 to 14 K, and intrinsic strains from –1.1% to +0.3%). The results are summarized in terms of the general USL parameters given in table 3 of Part 1 (Ekin J W 2010 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 23 083001 ) of this series of articles. The scaling constants determined for practical Nb 3 Sn conductors are: the upper-critical-field temperature parameter v = 1.50 ± 0.04; the cross-link parameter w = 3.0 ± 0.3; and the strain curvature parameter u = 1.7 ± 0.1 (from equation (29) for b c2 ( ε ) in Part 1). These constants and required fitting parameters result in the ESE relation, given by I c ( B,T,ε ) B = C [ b c2 ( ε )] S (1− t 1.5 ) η − μ (1- t 2 ) μ b p (1− b ) q with reduced magnetic field b ≡ B / B c2 *( T , ε ) and reduced temperature t ≡ T / T c *( ε ), where: B c2 * ( T , ε ) = B c2 * (0,0)(1− t 1.5 ) b c2 ( ε ) T c * (ε)= T c * (0)[ b c2 ( ε )] 1/3 and fitting parameters: C , B c2 *(0,0), T c *(0), s , either η or μ (but not both), plus the parameters in the strain function b c2 ( ε ). The pinning-force shape parameters p and q are also preferably fitted (simultaneously with the other parameters), but default values p = 0.5 and q = 2.0 also give high fitting accuracy when the range of relative magnetic fields is not extensive. Default values are also essential when the magnetic field data range is insufficient to determine p and q . The scaling constants are remarkably stable (changes less than ∼1%) with respect to different values of p and q , Nb 3 Sn conductor configurations, magnetic self-field corrections, and pinning-force trim values. The results demonstrate that the scaling of transport critical current holds down to the lowest temperatures measured ∼2.2 K, for both magnetic self-field corrected and uncorrected data. An initial comparison is also made between transport and magnetization scaling data in matched Nb 3 Sn samples and significant differences are found, especially for the upper critical field B c2
OpenAlex reports 24 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Abstract A scaling study of several thousand Nb 3 Sn critical-current ( I c ) measurements is used to derive the Extrapolative Scaling Expression (ESE), a relation that can quickly and accurately extrapolate limited datasets to obtain full three-dimensional dependences of I c on magnetic field ( B ), temperature ( T ), and mechanical strain ( ε ). The relation has the advantage of being easy to implement, and offers significant savings in sample characterization time and a useful tool for magnet design. Thorough data-based analysis of the general parameterization of the Unified Scaling Law (USL) shows the existence of three universal scaling constants for practical Nb 3 Sn conductors. The study also identifies the scaling parameters that are conductor specific and need to be fitted to each conductor. This investigation includes two new, rare, and very large I c ( B , T , ε ) datasets (each with nearly a thousand I c measurements spanning magnetic fields from 1 to 16 T, temperatures from ∼2.26 to 14 K, and intrinsic strains from –1.1% to +0.3%). The results are summarized in terms of the general USL parameters given in table 3 of Part 1 (Ekin J W 2010 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 23 083001 ) of this series of articles. The scaling constants determined for practical Nb 3 Sn conductors are: the upper-critical-field temperature parameter v = 1.50 ± 0.04; the cross-link parameter w = 3.0 ± 0.3; and the strain curvature parameter u = 1.7 ± 0.1 (from equation (29) for b c2 ( ε ) in Part 1). These constants and required fitting parameters result in the ESE relation, given by I c ( B,T,ε ) B = C [ b c2 ( ε )] S (1− t 1.5 ) η − μ (1- t 2 ) μ b p (1− b ) q with reduced magnetic field b ≡ B / B c2 *( T , ε ) and reduced temperature t ≡ T / T c *( ε ), where: B c2 * ( T , ε ) = B c2 * (0,0)(1− t 1.5 ) b c2 ( ε ) T c * (ε)= T c * (0)[ b c2 ( ε )] 1/3 and fitting parameters: C , B c2 *(0,0), T c *(0), s , either η or μ (but not both), plus the parameters in the strain function b c2 ( ε ). The pinning-force shape parameters p and q are also preferably fitted (simultaneously with the other parameters), but default values p = 0.5 and q = 2.0 also give high fitting accuracy when the range of relative magnetic fields is not extensive. Default values are also essential when the magnetic field data range is insufficient to determine p and q . The scaling constants are remarkably stable (changes less than ∼1%) with respect to different values of p and q , Nb 3 Sn conductor configurations, magnetic self-field corrections, and pinning-force trim values. The results demonstrate that the scaling of transport critical current holds down to the lowest temperatures measured ∼2.2 K, for both magnetic self-field corrected and uncorrected data. An initial comparison is also made between transport and magnetization scaling data in matched Nb 3 Sn samples and significant differences are found, especially for the upper critical field B c2
Key concepts: Scaling, Scaling law, Flux (metallurgy), Superconductivity, Statistical physics, Physics, Expression (computer science), Flux pinning