2016•arXiv (Cornell University)Open access

On the connection between Nonstandard Analysis and Computability Theory

Sam Sanders

Open full text 0 citations

Abstract

As reported in [11-14], higher-order computability results (including Reverse Mathematics) can be extracted from a large class of theorems in Nonstandard Analysis (NSA). Two possible points of criticism regarding these results are as follows: (1) Classical computabilitytheory and Friedman-Simpson-style ReverseMathematics do not really deal with higher type objects (beyond zero and one). Is it possible to obtain low type (i.e. second-order) computability theoretic results (including Reverse Mathematics) from NSA? (2) So-called Weihrauch reducibility provides a computability theoretic classification of mathematical theorems which takes into account the use of resources. Is it possible to obtain resource-sensitive results in computability theory from NSA? In this paper, we provide partial positive answers to these questions. The crux of our approach is the replacement in theorems of NSA of all type one quantifiers by (type zero) quantifiers over all A-computable functions, for some oracle A which appears as a parameter. This operation sufficiently lowers all types involved and also leads to resource sensitive results. We discuss an example based on the monotone convergence theorem, and one based on weak Koenig's lemma. We make essential use of the ECF-translation.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

As reported in [11-14], higher-order computability results (including Reverse Mathematics) can be extracted from a large class of theorems in Nonstandard Analysis (NSA). Two possible points of criticism regarding these results are as follows: (1) Classical computabilitytheory and Friedman-Simpson-style ReverseMathematics do not really deal with higher type objects (beyond zero and one). Is it possible to obtain low type (i.e. second-order) computability theoretic results (including Reverse Mathematics) from NSA? (2) So-called Weihrauch reducibility provides a computability theoretic classification of mathematical theorems which takes into account the use of resources. Is it possible to obtain resource-sensitive results in computability theory from NSA? In this paper, we provide partial positive answers to these questions. The crux of our approach is the replacement in theorems of NSA of all type one quantifiers by (type zero) quantifiers over all A-computable functions, for some oracle A which appears as a parameter. This operation sufficiently lowers all types involved and also leads to resource sensitive results. We discuss an example based on the monotone convergence theorem, and one based on weak Koenig's lemma. We make essential use of the ECF-translation.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

As reported in [11-14], higher-order computability results (including Reverse Mathematics) can be extracted from a large class of theorems in Nonstandard Analysis (NSA). Two possible points of criticism regarding these results are as follows: (1) Classical computabilitytheory and Friedman-Simpson-style ReverseMathematics do not really deal with higher type objects (beyond zero and one). Is it possible to obtain low type (i.e. second-order) computability theoretic results (including Reverse Mathematics) from NSA? (2) So-called Weihrauch reducibility provides a computability theoretic classification of mathematical theorems which takes into account the use of resources. Is it possible to obtain resource-sensitive results in computability theory from NSA? In this paper, we provide partial positive answers to these questions. The crux of our approach is the replacement in theorems of NSA of all type one quantifiers by (type zero) quantifiers over all A-computable functions, for some oracle A which appears as a parameter. This operation sufficiently lowers all types involved and also leads to resource sensitive results. We discuss an example based on the monotone convergence theorem, and one based on weak Koenig's lemma. We make essential use of the ECF-translation.

Key concepts: Computability, Reverse mathematics, Lemma (botany), Computability theory, Monotone polygon, Type (biology), Mathematics, Discrete mathematics

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
On the connection between Nonstandard Analysis and Computability Theory — Research Paper | ScholarLens