1. What is Truth?
Paul Horwich
Abstract
Paul Horwich
Abstract
This chapter begins by describing a traditional conception of truth whereby (a) it's a profound property; (b) we want our beliefs to possess it; and (c) a good theory of its underlying nature will enable us to explain why true beliefs are desirable and how best to obtain them. But there are well-known objections to each of the specific theories of that sort (which analyze truth in terms of correspondence with facts, or verifiability, or pragmatic utility, or consensus). A non-traditional perspective, known as ‘deflationism’, is then introduced, according to which no such analysis should ever have been expected. For our concept of truth is not that of a property with some hidden nature awaiting our discovery. Rather, it's a superficial expressive device whose utility and mode of deployment are fully captured by the trivial equivalence of ‘ is true’ and ‘p’. The chapter ends by deploying this idea in a critical discussion of the recently revived idea that our beliefs (at least within certain domains) are never absolutely true or false, but possess their truth-values only relative to a context of assessment.
OpenAlex reports 3 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
This chapter begins by describing a traditional conception of truth whereby (a) it's a profound property; (b) we want our beliefs to possess it; and (c) a good theory of its underlying nature will enable us to explain why true beliefs are desirable and how best to obtain them. But there are well-known objections to each of the specific theories of that sort (which analyze truth in terms of correspondence with facts, or verifiability, or pragmatic utility, or consensus). A non-traditional perspective, known as ‘deflationism’, is then introduced, according to which no such analysis should ever have been expected. For our concept of truth is not that of a property with some hidden nature awaiting our discovery. Rather, it's a superficial expressive device whose utility and mode of deployment are fully captured by the trivial equivalence of ‘ is true’ and ‘p’. The chapter ends by deploying this idea in a critical discussion of the recently revived idea that our beliefs (at least within certain domains) are never absolutely true or false, but possess their truth-values only relative to a context of assessment.
Key concepts: Computer science