1999PubMedRequires access

[The homeopathic patient: comparative results of homeopathic and conventional GP patient interviews].

Max L. Gunther

Open publisher page 3 citations

Abstract

This paper compares the results of homeopathic and conventional patient interviews. It is based on data from 284 patient interviews, conducted by 14 General Practitioners in 1993-94. Homeopathic treatment was used with 174 of the patients, while 110 were treated using conventional methods. In this sample, homeopathic patients were younger and better educated than those treated conventionally. They tended to be involved in pedagogy, health-care and social services. Their knowledge of homeopathy is often minimal, yet their expectations concerning their illnesses and treatment often reflect homeopathic concepts. Apparently, their general life view corresponds to certain parts of homeopathic philosophy. Homeopathic patients are more critical of medicine in general, and often have negative experiences with conventional medicine. Conventionally treated patients and homeopathically treated patients are equally satisfied with their physicians and treatment. In some cases homeopathic treatment also had positive effects on the patient's mood, sleeping habits, etc. Homeopathic patients tend to have healthier lifestyles than the others. They tend to choose homeopathy for its perceived effectiveness, which is largely based on their own experience, and that of other persons in their social surroundings. Most of the homeopathic patients receive social support for homeopathy. They actively recommend homeopathy and regularly meet others who are also treated homeopathically. Dissatisfaction and negative experiences with conventional treatment may be one reason for turning to homeopathy initially. Long-lasting reasons to continue using homeopathy are: effectiveness, good care of the homeopathic doctors, congruence with the patient's world-view, and greater patient responsibility for his/her own health.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

This paper compares the results of homeopathic and conventional patient interviews. It is based on data from 284 patient interviews, conducted by 14 General Practitioners in 1993-94. Homeopathic treatment was used with 174 of the patients, while 110 were treated using conventional methods. In this sample, homeopathic patients were younger and better educated than those treated conventionally. They tended to be involved in pedagogy, health-care and social services. Their knowledge of homeopathy is often minimal, yet their expectations concerning their illnesses and treatment often reflect homeopathic concepts. Apparently, their general life view corresponds to certain parts of homeopathic philosophy. Homeopathic patients are more critical of medicine in general, and often have negative experiences with conventional medicine. Conventionally treated patients and homeopathically treated patients are equally satisfied with their physicians and treatment. In some cases homeopathic treatment also had positive effects on the patient's mood, sleeping habits, etc. Homeopathic patients tend to have healthier lifestyles than the others. They tend to choose homeopathy for its perceived effectiveness, which is largely based on their own experience, and that of other persons in their social surroundings. Most of the homeopathic patients receive social support for homeopathy. They actively recommend homeopathy and regularly meet others who are also treated homeopathically. Dissatisfaction and negative experiences with conventional treatment may be one reason for turning to homeopathy initially. Long-lasting reasons to continue using homeopathy are: effectiveness, good care of the homeopathic doctors, congruence with the patient's world-view, and greater patient responsibility for his/her own health.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 3 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

This paper compares the results of homeopathic and conventional patient interviews. It is based on data from 284 patient interviews, conducted by 14 General Practitioners in 1993-94. Homeopathic treatment was used with 174 of the patients, while 110 were treated using conventional methods. In this sample, homeopathic patients were younger and better educated than those treated conventionally. They tended to be involved in pedagogy, health-care and social services. Their knowledge of homeopathy is often minimal, yet their expectations concerning their illnesses and treatment often reflect homeopathic concepts. Apparently, their general life view corresponds to certain parts of homeopathic philosophy. Homeopathic patients are more critical of medicine in general, and often have negative experiences with conventional medicine. Conventionally treated patients and homeopathically treated patients are equally satisfied with their physicians and treatment. In some cases homeopathic treatment also had positive effects on the patient's mood, sleeping habits, etc. Homeopathic patients tend to have healthier lifestyles than the others. They tend to choose homeopathy for its perceived effectiveness, which is largely based on their own experience, and that of other persons in their social surroundings. Most of the homeopathic patients receive social support for homeopathy. They actively recommend homeopathy and regularly meet others who are also treated homeopathically. Dissatisfaction and negative experiences with conventional treatment may be one reason for turning to homeopathy initially. Long-lasting reasons to continue using homeopathy are: effectiveness, good care of the homeopathic doctors, congruence with the patient's world-view, and greater patient responsibility for his/her own health.

Key concepts: Homeopathy, Homeopathic medicine, Medicine, Alternative medicine, Mood, Naturopathy, Family medicine, Traditional medicine

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
[The homeopathic patient: comparative results of homeopathic and conventional GP patient interviews]. — Research Paper | ScholarLens