2007Xiandai faxueRequires access

Rule by Criminal Law in a Harmonious Society

Wei Dong

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

Rule by criminal law is indispensable in building a harmonious society while justification and leniency of criminal policies should be especially examined and reconsidered so as to balance criminal control and protection of human rights.In logic,one-sided stress of retributivism and taking the idea that retributivism inheres in criminal law as an axiom is highly problematical.To justify a criminal policy,one should not only have a rough idea of the regular pattern of crimes,generally appreciate the criminal situation,clearly know the available physical,spiritual and cultural resources and the development of society,and fully respect human rights,but also have a right attitude in relationship with human nature as we employ reliable evaluation criteria in a specific historical stage.The notion of leniency and tolerance contained in existing criminal policies fully indicates that we should try our best to protect hu- man rights,promote social development and administer comparative justice while maintaining necessary order within a minimum area(re:the idea of“three maximums and one minimum”).In short,modern criminal policies should maintain“supremacy of human rights,”rather than“supremacy of criminal control,”and maintain“supremacy of justice,”rather than“supremacy of efficiency.”

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Rule by criminal law is indispensable in building a harmonious society while justification and leniency of criminal policies should be especially examined and reconsidered so as to balance criminal control and protection of human rights.In logic,one-sided stress of retributivism and taking the idea that retributivism inheres in criminal law as an axiom is highly problematical.To justify a criminal policy,one should not only have a rough idea of the regular pattern of crimes,generally appreciate the criminal situation,clearly know the available physical,spiritual and cultural resources and the development of society,and fully respect human rights,but also have a right attitude in relationship with human nature as we employ reliable evaluation criteria in a specific historical stage.The notion of leniency and tolerance contained in existing criminal policies fully indicates that we should try our best to protect hu- man rights,promote social development and administer comparative justice while maintaining necessary order within a minimum area(re:the idea of“three maximums and one minimum”).In short,modern criminal policies should maintain“supremacy of human rights,”rather than“supremacy of criminal control,”and maintain“supremacy of justice,”rather than“supremacy of efficiency.”

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Rule by criminal law is indispensable in building a harmonious society while justification and leniency of criminal policies should be especially examined and reconsidered so as to balance criminal control and protection of human rights.In logic,one-sided stress of retributivism and taking the idea that retributivism inheres in criminal law as an axiom is highly problematical.To justify a criminal policy,one should not only have a rough idea of the regular pattern of crimes,generally appreciate the criminal situation,clearly know the available physical,spiritual and cultural resources and the development of society,and fully respect human rights,but also have a right attitude in relationship with human nature as we employ reliable evaluation criteria in a specific historical stage.The notion of leniency and tolerance contained in existing criminal policies fully indicates that we should try our best to protect hu- man rights,promote social development and administer comparative justice while maintaining necessary order within a minimum area(re:the idea of“three maximums and one minimum”).In short,modern criminal policies should maintain“supremacy of human rights,”rather than“supremacy of criminal control,”and maintain“supremacy of justice,”rather than“supremacy of efficiency.”

Key concepts: Retributive justice, Criminal law, Law, Human rights, Criminal justice, Criminal procedure, Theory of criminal justice, Political science

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Rule by Criminal Law in a Harmonious Society — Research Paper | ScholarLens