Cost-benefit Analysis and Intergenerational Equity:A New Intergenerational Discounting Approach
QU Fu-tian
Abstract
QU Fu-tian
Abstract
Becanse of the harm to intergenerational equity,cost-benefit analysis has been thought of as an invalid instrument for evaluating the projects and policies with long-term impacts on natural resources and environment.It,therefores is a research focus on how to adapt cost-benefit analysis to these projects and policies at present.From the perspective of sustainable development theory,the paper,first,conducts a comparative analysis of the background,calculation methods and application scopes of four sorts of representative intergenerational discount rates including experimentation-oriented intergenerational discount rate,zero social discount rate,unitary environmental discount rate and dual social discount rate.Then it establishes a new intergenerational discounting approach which centers on multi-social discount rate,and last,a new discounting approach is simulated in a numerical simulation way with an example of water and soil conservation project.It is concluded that:①multi-social discount rate is superior to the four sorts of representative intergenerational discount rates in terms of evaluating the projects and policies with long-term and complicated impacts on natural resources and environment;②the new intergenerational discounting approach centered on multi-social discount rate could provide systematic guidance to how to select discount rate in the evaluation process of projects and policies;③each environmental discount rate in the framework of multi-social discount rate must be estimated in accordance with the principle that it decreases in time span and in the difficulty of substitution between man-made capital and environmental resources.The paper ends up with the policy implication of establishing a stakeholder of multi-discipline experts and compiling a discount rate table.
OpenAlex reports 1 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Becanse of the harm to intergenerational equity,cost-benefit analysis has been thought of as an invalid instrument for evaluating the projects and policies with long-term impacts on natural resources and environment.It,therefores is a research focus on how to adapt cost-benefit analysis to these projects and policies at present.From the perspective of sustainable development theory,the paper,first,conducts a comparative analysis of the background,calculation methods and application scopes of four sorts of representative intergenerational discount rates including experimentation-oriented intergenerational discount rate,zero social discount rate,unitary environmental discount rate and dual social discount rate.Then it establishes a new intergenerational discounting approach which centers on multi-social discount rate,and last,a new discounting approach is simulated in a numerical simulation way with an example of water and soil conservation project.It is concluded that:①multi-social discount rate is superior to the four sorts of representative intergenerational discount rates in terms of evaluating the projects and policies with long-term and complicated impacts on natural resources and environment;②the new intergenerational discounting approach centered on multi-social discount rate could provide systematic guidance to how to select discount rate in the evaluation process of projects and policies;③each environmental discount rate in the framework of multi-social discount rate must be estimated in accordance with the principle that it decreases in time span and in the difficulty of substitution between man-made capital and environmental resources.The paper ends up with the policy implication of establishing a stakeholder of multi-discipline experts and compiling a discount rate table.
Key concepts: Intergenerational equity, Discounting, Social discount rate, Economics, Equity (law), Microeconomics, Cost–benefit analysis, Actuarial science