2011•Journal of Shaanxi Normal UniversityRequires access

On Renaming the "Chinese History of Literary Criticism" to the "Chinese History of Poetic Prose Criticism"

DU Shu-ying

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

prose criticism differs from western criticism with its distinctive national characteristics.The two are similar in appearance but different in essence.No one can deny the fact that there is enormous discrepancy between prose criticism and its western counterpart.Thus the crucial reason for those negative effects from borrowing western concepts and terms of criticism is that some scholars care more about similarities and commensurability between and western literary theories than about discrepancies and incommensurability between the two theories.In fact,however,it is depending upon respective discrepancies,incommensurability and difference,namely,its own characteristics,that a national literature gains its identity and value of existence in global life.Therefore,we should cease to mechanically apply western academic and disciplinary titles by forcing the name of criticism on ancient literary theory.The prose criticism,the original name of literary criticism,should be restored,and the Chinese history of literary criticism should also be renamed as the Chinese history of poetic prose criticism.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

prose criticism differs from western criticism with its distinctive national characteristics.The two are similar in appearance but different in essence.No one can deny the fact that there is enormous discrepancy between prose criticism and its western counterpart.Thus the crucial reason for those negative effects from borrowing western concepts and terms of criticism is that some scholars care more about similarities and commensurability between and western literary theories than about discrepancies and incommensurability between the two theories.In fact,however,it is depending upon respective discrepancies,incommensurability and difference,namely,its own characteristics,that a national literature gains its identity and value of existence in global life.Therefore,we should cease to mechanically apply western academic and disciplinary titles by forcing the name of criticism on ancient literary theory.The prose criticism,the original name of literary criticism,should be restored,and the Chinese history of literary criticism should also be renamed as the Chinese history of poetic prose criticism.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

prose criticism differs from western criticism with its distinctive national characteristics.The two are similar in appearance but different in essence.No one can deny the fact that there is enormous discrepancy between prose criticism and its western counterpart.Thus the crucial reason for those negative effects from borrowing western concepts and terms of criticism is that some scholars care more about similarities and commensurability between and western literary theories than about discrepancies and incommensurability between the two theories.In fact,however,it is depending upon respective discrepancies,incommensurability and difference,namely,its own characteristics,that a national literature gains its identity and value of existence in global life.Therefore,we should cease to mechanically apply western academic and disciplinary titles by forcing the name of criticism on ancient literary theory.The prose criticism,the original name of literary criticism,should be restored,and the Chinese history of literary criticism should also be renamed as the Chinese history of poetic prose criticism.

Key concepts: Criticism, Literary criticism, Sociological criticism, Literature, Historical criticism, Commensurability (mathematics), Literary science, Poetry

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source