2016Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic ScienceOpen access

Total Replacement of Fishmeal by Soybean Meal with or Without Methionine Fortification in the Diets of Nile Tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus

E.K. Ajani, Olugbenga Orisasona, BO Omitoyin, Friday Elijah Osho

Open full text 26 citations

Abstract

The high cost and competing demand for fish meal in fish diet has made the search for alternative ingredient very expedient.A 12 week feeding trial was conducted with Oreochromis niloticus to determine the effect of replacing fishmeal with soyabean meal and methionine on growth, nutrient utilization, haematology and plasma biochemistry.Four experimental diets (40% crude protein) were formulated, with Partial Soybean Meal (PSM) inclusion, No Soyabean Meal (NSM), Only Soybean Meal (OSM) and soybean meal and methionine.For 84 days, fish were fed at 3% body weight daily to triplicate groups of 15 fish (25.08 g±0.04 g fishG 1 ) that were randomly allocated to twelve hapa suspended in 20 m 2 earthen pond.Results showed that Mean Weight Gain (MWG) and increase in length were significantly high (p<0.05) in PSM (22.77 g and 16.90 cm, respectively) and least in NSM (17.54 g and 14.63 cm, respectively).Specific Growth Rate (SGR) values were high in PSM (1.62) and OSM+M (1.55) and least in NSM (1.48).Fish fed OSM+M had the highest Parked Cell Volume (PCV, 20.66%), haemoglobin (Hb, 7.87 g dLG 1 ) and least White Blood Cells (WBC, 3.12x10 4 mmG 3 ), while NSM gave the least Hb (5.37 g dLG 1 ) and highest WBC (3.92x10 4 mmG 3 ).Serum enzymes AST (68.0 U LG 1 ) and ALT (46.66 U LG 1 ) were high in OSM+M and least in PSM (47.66 and 28.64 U LG 1 , respectively).The present study revealed that soybean meal can either be used to partially replace fishmeal or completely replace it with methionine supplementation, when growth, nutrient utilization and health status of O. niloticus are considered.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The high cost and competing demand for fish meal in fish diet has made the search for alternative ingredient very expedient.A 12 week feeding trial was conducted with Oreochromis niloticus to determine the effect of replacing fishmeal with soyabean meal and methionine on growth, nutrient utilization, haematology and plasma biochemistry.Four experimental diets (40% crude protein) were formulated, with Partial Soybean Meal (PSM) inclusion, No Soyabean Meal (NSM), Only Soybean Meal (OSM) and soybean meal and methionine.For 84 days, fish were fed at 3% body weight daily to triplicate groups of 15 fish (25.08 g±0.04 g fishG 1 ) that were randomly allocated to twelve hapa suspended in 20 m 2 earthen pond.Results showed that Mean Weight Gain (MWG) and increase in length were significantly high (p<0.05) in PSM (22.77 g and 16.90 cm, respectively) and least in NSM (17.54 g and 14.63 cm, respectively).Specific Growth Rate (SGR) values were high in PSM (1.62) and OSM+M (1.55) and least in NSM (1.48).Fish fed OSM+M had the highest Parked Cell Volume (PCV, 20.66%), haemoglobin (Hb, 7.87 g dLG 1 ) and least White Blood Cells (WBC, 3.12x10 4 mmG 3 ), while NSM gave the least Hb (5.37 g dLG 1 ) and highest WBC (3.92x10 4 mmG 3 ).Serum enzymes AST (68.0 U LG 1 ) and ALT (46.66 U LG 1 ) were high in OSM+M and least in PSM (47.66 and 28.64 U LG 1 , respectively).The present study revealed that soybean meal can either be used to partially replace fishmeal or completely replace it with methionine supplementation, when growth, nutrient utilization and health status of O. niloticus are considered.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 26 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The high cost and competing demand for fish meal in fish diet has made the search for alternative ingredient very expedient.A 12 week feeding trial was conducted with Oreochromis niloticus to determine the effect of replacing fishmeal with soyabean meal and methionine on growth, nutrient utilization, haematology and plasma biochemistry.Four experimental diets (40% crude protein) were formulated, with Partial Soybean Meal (PSM) inclusion, No Soyabean Meal (NSM), Only Soybean Meal (OSM) and soybean meal and methionine.For 84 days, fish were fed at 3% body weight daily to triplicate groups of 15 fish (25.08 g±0.04 g fishG 1 ) that were randomly allocated to twelve hapa suspended in 20 m 2 earthen pond.Results showed that Mean Weight Gain (MWG) and increase in length were significantly high (p<0.05) in PSM (22.77 g and 16.90 cm, respectively) and least in NSM (17.54 g and 14.63 cm, respectively).Specific Growth Rate (SGR) values were high in PSM (1.62) and OSM+M (1.55) and least in NSM (1.48).Fish fed OSM+M had the highest Parked Cell Volume (PCV, 20.66%), haemoglobin (Hb, 7.87 g dLG 1 ) and least White Blood Cells (WBC, 3.12x10 4 mmG 3 ), while NSM gave the least Hb (5.37 g dLG 1 ) and highest WBC (3.92x10 4 mmG 3 ).Serum enzymes AST (68.0 U LG 1 ) and ALT (46.66 U LG 1 ) were high in OSM+M and least in PSM (47.66 and 28.64 U LG 1 , respectively).The present study revealed that soybean meal can either be used to partially replace fishmeal or completely replace it with methionine supplementation, when growth, nutrient utilization and health status of O. niloticus are considered.

Key concepts: Oreochromis, Nile tilapia, Fish meal, Soybean meal, Food science, Fortification, Biology, Methionine

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Total Replacement of Fishmeal by Soybean Meal with or Without Methionine Fortification in the Diets of Nile Tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus — Research Paper | ScholarLens