2012•JOURNAL OF FISHERIES OF CHINARequires access

Effect of dietary replacement of fish meal protein with soybean meal proteinon the growth, body composition and hematology indices ofSchizothorax prenanti

Xiang Xiao, Xing-hua ZHOU, Jian Chen, Dai-jin LI, Wen-juan WANG, Xiao-qiu ZHOU

Open publisher page 5 citations

Abstract

This experiment was conducted to study the effect of replacement of fish meal by soybean meal protein on the growth,body composition and hematology indices of juvenile Schizothorax prenanti.Healthy S.prenanti [with the initial weight(14.67±0.51) g]were randomly divided into six groups with three replicates of 30 fish.Six isonitrogenous and isoenergetic diets were formulated to contain different levels of soybean meal based upon the basal diet to replace fish meal protein 0(A1),20%(A2),40%(A3),60%(A4),80%(A5) and 100%(A6).The experiment lasted for 45 days.The results showed that the weight gain ratio(WGR),the specific growth ratio(SGR) and protein efficiency ratio(PER) were highest(118.08%,1.95%/d,207.22%,respectively),the feed conversion ratio(FCR) was the lowest(1.27) when the replace-ment ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 60%(P0.05).The WGR,SGR,PER were signifi-cantly lower when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein of 100%,while the FCR was significantly higher than that of the other groups(P0.05).Based on quadratic regression analysis,the best replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 34.25% 45.46%.There were no significant difference in whole body moisture,crude ash and the condition factor(CF) with the replacement ratio of fish meal pro-tein by soybean meal increased,the crude protein in whole body was highest(15.53%) when the replace-ment ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 60%.The crude protein and lipid in whole body had no significant difference when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was less than 80%(P0.05).while the hepatopancreas somatic index(HIS) increased as soybean meal protein ratio in-creased,but there were no significant differences when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soy-bean meal was 0 80%(P0.05).Superoxide dismutase(SOD) activities have a certain fluctuation as soy-bean meal protein ratio increased,at the same time,SOD activities were highest when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 40%.Lysozyme(LSZ) activities were gradually increased when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 20% 60%(P0.05).The aspartate ami-notransferase(AST)and alanine aminotransferase(ALT)activities increased as soybean meal protein ratio increased,but there were no significant differences when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was less than 80%(P0.05).The AST and ALT activities were significantly higher than the control group and other experimental groups(P0.05).Results of above show that a certain percentage soybean meal protein ratio in diet could promote the growth,and improve feed protein metabolism and immunity of S.prenanti.In conclusion,the maximum replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 80% in the diets of S.prenanti,and the most suitable replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 34.25% 45.46%.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

This experiment was conducted to study the effect of replacement of fish meal by soybean meal protein on the growth,body composition and hematology indices of juvenile Schizothorax prenanti.Healthy S.prenanti [with the initial weight(14.67±0.51) g]were randomly divided into six groups with three replicates of 30 fish.Six isonitrogenous and isoenergetic diets were formulated to contain different levels of soybean meal based upon the basal diet to replace fish meal protein 0(A1),20%(A2),40%(A3),60%(A4),80%(A5) and 100%(A6).The experiment lasted for 45 days.The results showed that the weight gain ratio(WGR),the specific growth ratio(SGR) and protein efficiency ratio(PER) were highest(118.08%,1.95%/d,207.22%,respectively),the feed conversion ratio(FCR) was the lowest(1.27) when the replace-ment ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 60%(P0.05).The WGR,SGR,PER were signifi-cantly lower when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein of 100%,while the FCR was significantly higher than that of the other groups(P0.05).Based on quadratic regression analysis,the best replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 34.25% 45.46%.There were no significant difference in whole body moisture,crude ash and the condition factor(CF) with the replacement ratio of fish meal pro-tein by soybean meal increased,the crude protein in whole body was highest(15.53%) when the replace-ment ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 60%.The crude protein and lipid in whole body had no significant difference when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was less than 80%(P0.05).while the hepatopancreas somatic index(HIS) increased as soybean meal protein ratio in-creased,but there were no significant differences when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soy-bean meal was 0 80%(P0.05).Superoxide dismutase(SOD) activities have a certain fluctuation as soy-bean meal protein ratio increased,at the same time,SOD activities were highest when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 40%.Lysozyme(LSZ) activities were gradually increased when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 20% 60%(P0.05).The aspartate ami-notransferase(AST)and alanine aminotransferase(ALT)activities increased as soybean meal protein ratio increased,but there were no significant differences when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was less than 80%(P0.05).The AST and ALT activities were significantly higher than the control group and other experimental groups(P0.05).Results of above show that a certain percentage soybean meal protein ratio in diet could promote the growth,and improve feed protein metabolism and immunity of S.prenanti.In conclusion,the maximum replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 80% in the diets of S.prenanti,and the most suitable replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 34.25% 45.46%.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 5 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

This experiment was conducted to study the effect of replacement of fish meal by soybean meal protein on the growth,body composition and hematology indices of juvenile Schizothorax prenanti.Healthy S.prenanti [with the initial weight(14.67±0.51) g]were randomly divided into six groups with three replicates of 30 fish.Six isonitrogenous and isoenergetic diets were formulated to contain different levels of soybean meal based upon the basal diet to replace fish meal protein 0(A1),20%(A2),40%(A3),60%(A4),80%(A5) and 100%(A6).The experiment lasted for 45 days.The results showed that the weight gain ratio(WGR),the specific growth ratio(SGR) and protein efficiency ratio(PER) were highest(118.08%,1.95%/d,207.22%,respectively),the feed conversion ratio(FCR) was the lowest(1.27) when the replace-ment ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 60%(P0.05).The WGR,SGR,PER were signifi-cantly lower when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein of 100%,while the FCR was significantly higher than that of the other groups(P0.05).Based on quadratic regression analysis,the best replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 34.25% 45.46%.There were no significant difference in whole body moisture,crude ash and the condition factor(CF) with the replacement ratio of fish meal pro-tein by soybean meal increased,the crude protein in whole body was highest(15.53%) when the replace-ment ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 60%.The crude protein and lipid in whole body had no significant difference when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was less than 80%(P0.05).while the hepatopancreas somatic index(HIS) increased as soybean meal protein ratio in-creased,but there were no significant differences when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soy-bean meal was 0 80%(P0.05).Superoxide dismutase(SOD) activities have a certain fluctuation as soy-bean meal protein ratio increased,at the same time,SOD activities were highest when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 40%.Lysozyme(LSZ) activities were gradually increased when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 20% 60%(P0.05).The aspartate ami-notransferase(AST)and alanine aminotransferase(ALT)activities increased as soybean meal protein ratio increased,but there were no significant differences when the replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was less than 80%(P0.05).The AST and ALT activities were significantly higher than the control group and other experimental groups(P0.05).Results of above show that a certain percentage soybean meal protein ratio in diet could promote the growth,and improve feed protein metabolism and immunity of S.prenanti.In conclusion,the maximum replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 80% in the diets of S.prenanti,and the most suitable replacement ratio of fish meal protein by soybean meal was 34.25% 45.46%.

Key concepts: Biology, Soybean meal, Fish meal, Meal, Hematology, Composition (language), Fish <Actinopterygii>, Food science

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Effect of dietary replacement of fish meal protein with soybean meal proteinon the growth, body composition and hematology indices ofSchizothorax prenanti — Research Paper | ScholarLens