2002Unpublished venueRequires access

Effective generation of the Pareto frontier using the Normal Constraint method

Amir Ismail-Yahaya, Achille Messac

Open publisher page 32 citations

Abstract

In engineering optimization, Pareto solutions are those where improvement in one design objective can take place if at least one other design objective worsens. Accordingly Pareto solutions play an important role in engineering design. Some engineering design optimization methods automatically generate a Pareto solution as a possible final solution, while other methods generate a set of Pareto solutions from which one is chosen as final. For the latter approach to be successful, the generated Pareto set must be truly representative of the Pareto solutions in the design space. In other words, the set must not overly represent one region of the design space, while neglecting other regions. Many commonly used methods fail to comply with this requirement, while others do. This paper offers a new and simple method to generate an evenly spaced set of Pareto solutions in the design space. This method bears some similarities to the Normal Boundary Intersection and to the e-Constraint methods, and it works for an arbitrary number of objectives. The even spread of the generated Pareto solutions makes it possible to effectively develop an analytical expression for the Pareto frontier (complete set of Pareto solutions) in ^-dimension. This even spread also facilitates decision making in choosing the most desirable (final) Pareto solution.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

In engineering optimization, Pareto solutions are those where improvement in one design objective can take place if at least one other design objective worsens. Accordingly Pareto solutions play an important role in engineering design. Some engineering design optimization methods automatically generate a Pareto solution as a possible final solution, while other methods generate a set of Pareto solutions from which one is chosen as final. For the latter approach to be successful, the generated Pareto set must be truly representative of the Pareto solutions in the design space. In other words, the set must not overly represent one region of the design space, while neglecting other regions. Many commonly used methods fail to comply with this requirement, while others do. This paper offers a new and simple method to generate an evenly spaced set of Pareto solutions in the design space. This method bears some similarities to the Normal Boundary Intersection and to the e-Constraint methods, and it works for an arbitrary number of objectives. The even spread of the generated Pareto solutions makes it possible to effectively develop an analytical expression for the Pareto frontier (complete set of Pareto solutions) in ^-dimension. This even spread also facilitates decision making in choosing the most desirable (final) Pareto solution.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 32 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

In engineering optimization, Pareto solutions are those where improvement in one design objective can take place if at least one other design objective worsens. Accordingly Pareto solutions play an important role in engineering design. Some engineering design optimization methods automatically generate a Pareto solution as a possible final solution, while other methods generate a set of Pareto solutions from which one is chosen as final. For the latter approach to be successful, the generated Pareto set must be truly representative of the Pareto solutions in the design space. In other words, the set must not overly represent one region of the design space, while neglecting other regions. Many commonly used methods fail to comply with this requirement, while others do. This paper offers a new and simple method to generate an evenly spaced set of Pareto solutions in the design space. This method bears some similarities to the Normal Boundary Intersection and to the e-Constraint methods, and it works for an arbitrary number of objectives. The even spread of the generated Pareto solutions makes it possible to effectively develop an analytical expression for the Pareto frontier (complete set of Pareto solutions) in ^-dimension. This even spread also facilitates decision making in choosing the most desirable (final) Pareto solution.

Key concepts: Pareto principle, Frontier, Constraint (computer-aided design), Computer science, Mathematical optimization, Pareto interpolation, Pareto analysis, Mathematics

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Effective generation of the Pareto frontier using the Normal Constraint method — Research Paper | ScholarLens