2009Journal of Mathematics and StatisticsRequires access

Why College or University Students Hate Proofs in Mathematics?

Mbaà ̄tiga Zacharie

Open publisher page 1 citations

Abstract

Problem Statement: A proof is a notoriously difficult mathematical co ncept for students. Empirical studies have shown that students emerge f rom proof-oriented courses such as high-school geometry, introduction to proof, complex and abstra ct algebra unable to construct anything beyond very trivial proofs. Furthermore, most university s tudents do not know what constitutes a proof and cannot determine whether a purported proof is valid . A proof is a convincing method that demonstrates with generally accepted theorem that some mathematical statement is true and each proofs step must follow from previous proof steps and definition tha t have already been proved. To motivate students hating proofs and to help mathematics teachers, how a proof can be taught, we investigated in this study the idea of mathematical proofs. Approach: To tackle this issue, the modified Moore method and the researcher method called Z. Mbaitiga method are introduced follow by two cases studies on proof of triple integral. Next a survey is conducte d on fourth year college students on which of the proposed two cases study they understand easily or they like. Results: The result of the survey showed that more than 95% of the responded students pointe d out the proof that is done using details explanation of every theorem used in the proof cons truction, the case study2. Conclusion: From the result of this survey, we had learned that mathemat ics teachers have to be very careful about the selection of proofs to include when introducing top ics and filtering out some details which can obscur e important ideas and discourage students.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

Problem Statement: A proof is a notoriously difficult mathematical co ncept for students. Empirical studies have shown that students emerge f rom proof-oriented courses such as high-school geometry, introduction to proof, complex and abstra ct algebra unable to construct anything beyond very trivial proofs. Furthermore, most university s tudents do not know what constitutes a proof and cannot determine whether a purported proof is valid . A proof is a convincing method that demonstrates with generally accepted theorem that some mathematical statement is true and each proofs step must follow from previous proof steps and definition tha t have already been proved. To motivate students hating proofs and to help mathematics teachers, how a proof can be taught, we investigated in this study the idea of mathematical proofs. Approach: To tackle this issue, the modified Moore method and the researcher method called Z. Mbaitiga method are introduced follow by two cases studies on proof of triple integral. Next a survey is conducte d on fourth year college students on which of the proposed two cases study they understand easily or they like. Results: The result of the survey showed that more than 95% of the responded students pointe d out the proof that is done using details explanation of every theorem used in the proof cons truction, the case study2. Conclusion: From the result of this survey, we had learned that mathemat ics teachers have to be very careful about the selection of proofs to include when introducing top ics and filtering out some details which can obscur e important ideas and discourage students.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 1 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

Problem Statement: A proof is a notoriously difficult mathematical co ncept for students. Empirical studies have shown that students emerge f rom proof-oriented courses such as high-school geometry, introduction to proof, complex and abstra ct algebra unable to construct anything beyond very trivial proofs. Furthermore, most university s tudents do not know what constitutes a proof and cannot determine whether a purported proof is valid . A proof is a convincing method that demonstrates with generally accepted theorem that some mathematical statement is true and each proofs step must follow from previous proof steps and definition tha t have already been proved. To motivate students hating proofs and to help mathematics teachers, how a proof can be taught, we investigated in this study the idea of mathematical proofs. Approach: To tackle this issue, the modified Moore method and the researcher method called Z. Mbaitiga method are introduced follow by two cases studies on proof of triple integral. Next a survey is conducte d on fourth year college students on which of the proposed two cases study they understand easily or they like. Results: The result of the survey showed that more than 95% of the responded students pointe d out the proof that is done using details explanation of every theorem used in the proof cons truction, the case study2. Conclusion: From the result of this survey, we had learned that mathemat ics teachers have to be very careful about the selection of proofs to include when introducing top ics and filtering out some details which can obscur e important ideas and discourage students.

Key concepts: Mathematics, Mathematical proof, Mathematics education, Calculus (dental), Geometry, Dentistry, Medicine

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Why College or University Students Hate Proofs in Mathematics? — Research Paper | ScholarLens