1972Highway Research RecordRequires access

FREEZING AND HEAVING OF SATURATED AND UNSATURATED SOILS

Robert D. Miller

Open publisher page 258 citations

Abstract

ANALYSIS OF THE BEHAVIOR OF AIR--WATER, ICE--WATER, AND AIR--ICE INTERFACES SHOWS THAT THE APPARENT CONTACT ANGLE BETWEEN AN AIR--ICE INTERFACE AND THE WALL OF A SOIL PORE OUGHT TO VARY RAPIDLY WITH CHANGES IN PORE WATER PRESSURE AND ICE PRESSURE. THIS PAPER GIVES THE EXPECTED RELATIONSHIP AND SHOWS THAT COOLING OF FAIRLY DRY SOIL, WITH FREEZING NUCLEATED AT ONE SPOT, SHOULD CAUSE CERTAIN PORES TO FILL ABRUPTLY WITH ICE, THUS DEPLETING THE WATER CONTENT OF THE SURROUNDING SOIL. THIS CONCLUSION AGREES WITH AVAILABLE DATA. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THE ICE PRESSURE IS SLIGHTLY GREATER THAN ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE WHEN PORES FILL. LIMITED DATA AVAILABLE IN THE LITERATURE INDICATE THAT A GIVEN MOIST SOIL MAY OR MAY NOT HEAVE; WHEN IT DOES, THE ICE LENSES APPARENTLY FORM SOME DISTANCE BEHIND THE FREEZING FRONT. TO EXPLAIN THIS, THE CONCEPTS OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY HEAVING ARE PROPOSED FOR SATURATED SOIL. PRIMARY HEAVING OCCURS WHEN THE BASE OF THE GROWING ICE LENS COINCIDES WITH THE LIMIT OF FREEZING, AND THE RATE OF HEAVING IS LIMITED BY THE RATE OF HEAT EXTRACTION. SECONDARY HEAVING IS BELIEVED TO OCCUR WHEN THE FREEZING EXTENDS BELOW THE NOMINAL BASE OF THE (VISIBLE) ICE LENS. ICE IN THE FROZEN PORES CAN MOVE, RELATIVE TO THE PARTICLES, AS AN INTEGRAL PART OF THE GROWING LENS. A SOLUTION MODEL OF SECONDARY HEAVING IS USED TO ILLUSTRATE AN INCREASE OF ICE PRESSURE FROM THE FREEZING FRONT TO THE BASE OF THE ICE LENS, WHICH WILL OCCUR AT A POINT WHERE ICE PRESSURE IS EQUAL TO THE OVERBURDEN PRESSURE. IT IS CONTENTED THAT SECONDARY HEAVING PRODUCES LARGER HEAVING PRESSURES THAN PRIMARY HEAVING AND EXPLAINS WHY PREVIOUS THEORIES UNDERSTIMATED THE MAXIMUM HEAVING PRESSURE OF SATURATED SOIL. IT IS INFERRED THAT WHENEVER HEAVING OCCURS AS THE FREEZING FRONT IS DESCENDING THROUGH THE SOIL, THE PROCESS MUST BE SECONDARY HEAVING. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THE DEVELOPMENT OF SIGNIFICANT HEAVING PRESSURES BY UNSATURATED SOIL WILL ORDINARILY INVOLVE SECONDARY HEAVING AND THAT THE PRESSURE DEVELOPED IS LESS THAN THAT DEVELOPED BY THE SAME SOIL WHEN IT IS SATURATED. /AUTHOR/

About this research paper

What this paper is about

ANALYSIS OF THE BEHAVIOR OF AIR--WATER, ICE--WATER, AND AIR--ICE INTERFACES SHOWS THAT THE APPARENT CONTACT ANGLE BETWEEN AN AIR--ICE INTERFACE AND THE WALL OF A SOIL PORE OUGHT TO VARY RAPIDLY WITH CHANGES IN PORE WATER PRESSURE AND ICE PRESSURE. THIS PAPER GIVES THE EXPECTED RELATIONSHIP AND SHOWS THAT COOLING OF FAIRLY DRY SOIL, WITH FREEZING NUCLEATED AT ONE SPOT, SHOULD CAUSE CERTAIN PORES TO FILL ABRUPTLY WITH ICE, THUS DEPLETING THE WATER CONTENT OF THE SURROUNDING SOIL. THIS CONCLUSION AGREES WITH AVAILABLE DATA. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THE ICE PRESSURE IS SLIGHTLY GREATER THAN ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE WHEN PORES FILL. LIMITED DATA AVAILABLE IN THE LITERATURE INDICATE THAT A GIVEN MOIST SOIL MAY OR MAY NOT HEAVE; WHEN IT DOES, THE ICE LENSES APPARENTLY FORM SOME DISTANCE BEHIND THE FREEZING FRONT. TO EXPLAIN THIS, THE CONCEPTS OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY HEAVING ARE PROPOSED FOR SATURATED SOIL. PRIMARY HEAVING OCCURS WHEN THE BASE OF THE GROWING ICE LENS COINCIDES WITH THE LIMIT OF FREEZING, AND THE RATE OF HEAVING IS LIMITED BY THE RATE OF HEAT EXTRACTION. SECONDARY HEAVING IS BELIEVED TO OCCUR WHEN THE FREEZING EXTENDS BELOW THE NOMINAL BASE OF THE (VISIBLE) ICE LENS. ICE IN THE FROZEN PORES CAN MOVE, RELATIVE TO THE PARTICLES, AS AN INTEGRAL PART OF THE GROWING LENS. A SOLUTION MODEL OF SECONDARY HEAVING IS USED TO ILLUSTRATE AN INCREASE OF ICE PRESSURE FROM THE FREEZING FRONT TO THE BASE OF THE ICE LENS, WHICH WILL OCCUR AT A POINT WHERE ICE PRESSURE IS EQUAL TO THE OVERBURDEN PRESSURE. IT IS CONTENTED THAT SECONDARY HEAVING PRODUCES LARGER HEAVING PRESSURES THAN PRIMARY HEAVING AND EXPLAINS WHY PREVIOUS THEORIES UNDERSTIMATED THE MAXIMUM HEAVING PRESSURE OF SATURATED SOIL. IT IS INFERRED THAT WHENEVER HEAVING OCCURS AS THE FREEZING FRONT IS DESCENDING THROUGH THE SOIL, THE PROCESS MUST BE SECONDARY HEAVING. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THE DEVELOPMENT OF SIGNIFICANT HEAVING PRESSURES BY UNSATURATED SOIL WILL ORDINARILY INVOLVE SECONDARY HEAVING AND THAT THE PRESSURE DEVELOPED IS LESS THAN THAT DEVELOPED BY THE SAME SOIL WHEN IT IS SATURATED. /AUTHOR/

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 258 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

ANALYSIS OF THE BEHAVIOR OF AIR--WATER, ICE--WATER, AND AIR--ICE INTERFACES SHOWS THAT THE APPARENT CONTACT ANGLE BETWEEN AN AIR--ICE INTERFACE AND THE WALL OF A SOIL PORE OUGHT TO VARY RAPIDLY WITH CHANGES IN PORE WATER PRESSURE AND ICE PRESSURE. THIS PAPER GIVES THE EXPECTED RELATIONSHIP AND SHOWS THAT COOLING OF FAIRLY DRY SOIL, WITH FREEZING NUCLEATED AT ONE SPOT, SHOULD CAUSE CERTAIN PORES TO FILL ABRUPTLY WITH ICE, THUS DEPLETING THE WATER CONTENT OF THE SURROUNDING SOIL. THIS CONCLUSION AGREES WITH AVAILABLE DATA. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THE ICE PRESSURE IS SLIGHTLY GREATER THAN ATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE WHEN PORES FILL. LIMITED DATA AVAILABLE IN THE LITERATURE INDICATE THAT A GIVEN MOIST SOIL MAY OR MAY NOT HEAVE; WHEN IT DOES, THE ICE LENSES APPARENTLY FORM SOME DISTANCE BEHIND THE FREEZING FRONT. TO EXPLAIN THIS, THE CONCEPTS OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY HEAVING ARE PROPOSED FOR SATURATED SOIL. PRIMARY HEAVING OCCURS WHEN THE BASE OF THE GROWING ICE LENS COINCIDES WITH THE LIMIT OF FREEZING, AND THE RATE OF HEAVING IS LIMITED BY THE RATE OF HEAT EXTRACTION. SECONDARY HEAVING IS BELIEVED TO OCCUR WHEN THE FREEZING EXTENDS BELOW THE NOMINAL BASE OF THE (VISIBLE) ICE LENS. ICE IN THE FROZEN PORES CAN MOVE, RELATIVE TO THE PARTICLES, AS AN INTEGRAL PART OF THE GROWING LENS. A SOLUTION MODEL OF SECONDARY HEAVING IS USED TO ILLUSTRATE AN INCREASE OF ICE PRESSURE FROM THE FREEZING FRONT TO THE BASE OF THE ICE LENS, WHICH WILL OCCUR AT A POINT WHERE ICE PRESSURE IS EQUAL TO THE OVERBURDEN PRESSURE. IT IS CONTENTED THAT SECONDARY HEAVING PRODUCES LARGER HEAVING PRESSURES THAN PRIMARY HEAVING AND EXPLAINS WHY PREVIOUS THEORIES UNDERSTIMATED THE MAXIMUM HEAVING PRESSURE OF SATURATED SOIL. IT IS INFERRED THAT WHENEVER HEAVING OCCURS AS THE FREEZING FRONT IS DESCENDING THROUGH THE SOIL, THE PROCESS MUST BE SECONDARY HEAVING. IT IS SUGGESTED THAT THE DEVELOPMENT OF SIGNIFICANT HEAVING PRESSURES BY UNSATURATED SOIL WILL ORDINARILY INVOLVE SECONDARY HEAVING AND THAT THE PRESSURE DEVELOPED IS LESS THAN THAT DEVELOPED BY THE SAME SOIL WHEN IT IS SATURATED. /AUTHOR/

Key concepts: Frost heaving, Front (military), Soil water, Freezing point, Geotechnical engineering, Environmental science, Geology, Soil science

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
FREEZING AND HEAVING OF SATURATED AND UNSATURATED SOILS — Research Paper | ScholarLens