2012Unpublished venueRequires access

Progressive Consumption Taxation: The X-Tax Revisited

Robert Carroll, Alan D. Viard

Open publisher page 16 citations

Abstract

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS INTRODUCTION 1. WHY TAX CONSUMPTION? Removing the Income Tax Penalty on Saving Gains from Reform Consumption-Tax Features in the Current Income Tax System Conclusion Box: The Trade-off Fallacy 2. THE CASE FOR THE X TAX The Retail Sales Tax and the Value-Added Tax The Two-Part VAT The X Tax: A Progressive Two-Part VAT Comparing the X Tax to the Personal Expenditures Tax Conclusion Box: Optics of the X Tax and the PET 3. MAINTAINING PROGRESSIVITY Tax Rate Schedule Assessing the Distributional Effects of the X Tax Conclusion Box: Zero Revenue from Taxation of Risky Returns 4. FRINGE BENEFITS AND TRANSFER PAYMENTS Fringe Benefits Financing Social Security and Medicare Public and Private Transfer Payments Conclusion Box: Taxation of Gambling 5. BUSINESS FIRMS General Issues Distinguishing Wages from Business Cash Flow Firms with Negative Business Cash Flows Conclusion 6. FINANCIAL SERVICES Neutral Tax Treatment The Problem of Mislabeled Transactions The Search for a Solution The R+F Cash-Flow Method Accounting Methods Special Cases Conclusion 7. INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS The Border Adjustment Question The Competitiveness Illusion Giving Wealth Away without Really Trying Above-Normal Returns and Transfer Pricing Other Cross-Border Issues Conclusion Box: Border Adjustment with Fixed Exchange Rates 8. THE TRANSITION Transition Burden on Existing Capital Normative Issues Outline of a Transition Policy Macroeconomic Policy during the Transition Conclusion 9. THE NONBUSINESS SECTOR Owner-Occupied Housing and Consumer Durables Production by Governments, Nonprofits, and Households Patrolling the Boundaries of the Business Cash-Flow Tax Fiscal Federalism under the X Tax Conclusion Box: Taxation of Home Resales 10. THE VAT ALTERNATIVE Subtraction and Credit-Invoice VATs The Superiority of the VAT to the Retail Sales Tax Recent Discussion of VAT Using the VAT to Replace Other Taxes The Easy Stuff Monetary Policy and Other Transition Issues Governments and Nonprofits Implications for Social Security Combating the Money Machine Conclusion CONCLUSION NOTES REFERENCES INDEX ABOUT THE AUTHORS

About this research paper

What this paper is about

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS INTRODUCTION 1. WHY TAX CONSUMPTION? Removing the Income Tax Penalty on Saving Gains from Reform Consumption-Tax Features in the Current Income Tax System Conclusion Box: The Trade-off Fallacy 2. THE CASE FOR THE X TAX The Retail Sales Tax and the Value-Added Tax The Two-Part VAT The X Tax: A Progressive Two-Part VAT Comparing the X Tax to the Personal Expenditures Tax Conclusion Box: Optics of the X Tax and the PET 3. MAINTAINING PROGRESSIVITY Tax Rate Schedule Assessing the Distributional Effects of the X Tax Conclusion Box: Zero Revenue from Taxation of Risky Returns 4. FRINGE BENEFITS AND TRANSFER PAYMENTS Fringe Benefits Financing Social Security and Medicare Public and Private Transfer Payments Conclusion Box: Taxation of Gambling 5. BUSINESS FIRMS General Issues Distinguishing Wages from Business Cash Flow Firms with Negative Business Cash Flows Conclusion 6. FINANCIAL SERVICES Neutral Tax Treatment The Problem of Mislabeled Transactions The Search for a Solution The R+F Cash-Flow Method Accounting Methods Special Cases Conclusion 7. INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS The Border Adjustment Question The Competitiveness Illusion Giving Wealth Away without Really Trying Above-Normal Returns and Transfer Pricing Other Cross-Border Issues Conclusion Box: Border Adjustment with Fixed Exchange Rates 8. THE TRANSITION Transition Burden on Existing Capital Normative Issues Outline of a Transition Policy Macroeconomic Policy during the Transition Conclusion 9. THE NONBUSINESS SECTOR Owner-Occupied Housing and Consumer Durables Production by Governments, Nonprofits, and Households Patrolling the Boundaries of the Business Cash-Flow Tax Fiscal Federalism under the X Tax Conclusion Box: Taxation of Home Resales 10. THE VAT ALTERNATIVE Subtraction and Credit-Invoice VATs The Superiority of the VAT to the Retail Sales Tax Recent Discussion of VAT Using the VAT to Replace Other Taxes The Easy Stuff Monetary Policy and Other Transition Issues Governments and Nonprofits Implications for Social Security Combating the Money Machine Conclusion CONCLUSION NOTES REFERENCES INDEX ABOUT THE AUTHORS

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 16 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ACKNOWLEDGMENTS INTRODUCTION 1. WHY TAX CONSUMPTION? Removing the Income Tax Penalty on Saving Gains from Reform Consumption-Tax Features in the Current Income Tax System Conclusion Box: The Trade-off Fallacy 2. THE CASE FOR THE X TAX The Retail Sales Tax and the Value-Added Tax The Two-Part VAT The X Tax: A Progressive Two-Part VAT Comparing the X Tax to the Personal Expenditures Tax Conclusion Box: Optics of the X Tax and the PET 3. MAINTAINING PROGRESSIVITY Tax Rate Schedule Assessing the Distributional Effects of the X Tax Conclusion Box: Zero Revenue from Taxation of Risky Returns 4. FRINGE BENEFITS AND TRANSFER PAYMENTS Fringe Benefits Financing Social Security and Medicare Public and Private Transfer Payments Conclusion Box: Taxation of Gambling 5. BUSINESS FIRMS General Issues Distinguishing Wages from Business Cash Flow Firms with Negative Business Cash Flows Conclusion 6. FINANCIAL SERVICES Neutral Tax Treatment The Problem of Mislabeled Transactions The Search for a Solution The R+F Cash-Flow Method Accounting Methods Special Cases Conclusion 7. INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS The Border Adjustment Question The Competitiveness Illusion Giving Wealth Away without Really Trying Above-Normal Returns and Transfer Pricing Other Cross-Border Issues Conclusion Box: Border Adjustment with Fixed Exchange Rates 8. THE TRANSITION Transition Burden on Existing Capital Normative Issues Outline of a Transition Policy Macroeconomic Policy during the Transition Conclusion 9. THE NONBUSINESS SECTOR Owner-Occupied Housing and Consumer Durables Production by Governments, Nonprofits, and Households Patrolling the Boundaries of the Business Cash-Flow Tax Fiscal Federalism under the X Tax Conclusion Box: Taxation of Home Resales 10. THE VAT ALTERNATIVE Subtraction and Credit-Invoice VATs The Superiority of the VAT to the Retail Sales Tax Recent Discussion of VAT Using the VAT to Replace Other Taxes The Easy Stuff Monetary Policy and Other Transition Issues Governments and Nonprofits Implications for Social Security Combating the Money Machine Conclusion CONCLUSION NOTES REFERENCES INDEX ABOUT THE AUTHORS

Key concepts: Tax reform, Consumption tax, Indirect tax, Value-added tax, Economics, Monetary economics, Ad valorem tax, State income tax

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Progressive Consumption Taxation: The X-Tax Revisited — Research Paper | ScholarLens