2007Geo-Leo e-docs (Deutsche Initiative für Netzwerkinformation)Open access

Formation and stability of the solar tachocline in MHD simulations

Aniket Sule

Open full text 0 citations

Abstract

The solar tachocline is a thin transition layer between the solar radiative zone rotating uniformly and the solar convection zone, which has a mainly latitudinal differential rotation profile. This layer has a thickness of less than $0.05R_{\sun}$ and is subject to extreme radial as well as latitudinal shears. Helioseismological estimates put this layer at roughly $0.7R_{\sun}$. The tachocline mostly resides in the sub-adiabatic, non-turbulent radiative interior, except for a small overlap with the convection zone on the top. Many proposed dynamo mechanisms involve strong toroidal magnetic fields in this transition region. The exact mechanisms behind the formation of such a thin layer is still disputed. A very plausible mechanism is the one involving a weak, relic poloidal magnetic field trapped inside the radiative zone, which is responsible for expelling differential rotation outwards. This was first proposed by \citet{RK97}. The present work develops this idea with numerical simulations including additional effects like meridional circulation. It is shown that a relic field of 1~Gauss or smaller would be sufficient to explain the observed thickness of the tachocline. The stability of the solar tachocline is addressed as the next part of the problem. It is shown that the tachocline is stable up to a differential rotation of 52\% in the absence of magnetic fields. This is a new finding as compared to the earlier two dimensional models which estimated the solar differential rotation (about 28\%) to be marginally stable or even unstable. The changed stability limit is attributed to the changed stability criterion of the 3-dimensional model which also involves radial gradients of the angular velocity. In the presence of toroidal magnetic field belts, the lowest non-axisymmetric mode is shown to be the most unstable one for the radiative part of the tachocline. It is estimated that the tachocline would become unstable for toroidal fields exceeding about 100~Gauss. With both formation and stability questions satisfactorily addressed, this work presents the most comprehensive analysis of the physical processes in the solar tachocline to date.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The solar tachocline is a thin transition layer between the solar radiative zone rotating uniformly and the solar convection zone, which has a mainly latitudinal differential rotation profile. This layer has a thickness of less than $0.05R_{\sun}$ and is subject to extreme radial as well as latitudinal shears. Helioseismological estimates put this layer at roughly $0.7R_{\sun}$. The tachocline mostly resides in the sub-adiabatic, non-turbulent radiative interior, except for a small overlap with the convection zone on the top. Many proposed dynamo mechanisms involve strong toroidal magnetic fields in this transition region. The exact mechanisms behind the formation of such a thin layer is still disputed. A very plausible mechanism is the one involving a weak, relic poloidal magnetic field trapped inside the radiative zone, which is responsible for expelling differential rotation outwards. This was first proposed by \citet{RK97}. The present work develops this idea with numerical simulations including additional effects like meridional circulation. It is shown that a relic field of 1~Gauss or smaller would be sufficient to explain the observed thickness of the tachocline. The stability of the solar tachocline is addressed as the next part of the problem. It is shown that the tachocline is stable up to a differential rotation of 52\% in the absence of magnetic fields. This is a new finding as compared to the earlier two dimensional models which estimated the solar differential rotation (about 28\%) to be marginally stable or even unstable. The changed stability limit is attributed to the changed stability criterion of the 3-dimensional model which also involves radial gradients of the angular velocity. In the presence of toroidal magnetic field belts, the lowest non-axisymmetric mode is shown to be the most unstable one for the radiative part of the tachocline. It is estimated that the tachocline would become unstable for toroidal fields exceeding about 100~Gauss. With both formation and stability questions satisfactorily addressed, this work presents the most comprehensive analysis of the physical processes in the solar tachocline to date.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The solar tachocline is a thin transition layer between the solar radiative zone rotating uniformly and the solar convection zone, which has a mainly latitudinal differential rotation profile. This layer has a thickness of less than $0.05R_{\sun}$ and is subject to extreme radial as well as latitudinal shears. Helioseismological estimates put this layer at roughly $0.7R_{\sun}$. The tachocline mostly resides in the sub-adiabatic, non-turbulent radiative interior, except for a small overlap with the convection zone on the top. Many proposed dynamo mechanisms involve strong toroidal magnetic fields in this transition region. The exact mechanisms behind the formation of such a thin layer is still disputed. A very plausible mechanism is the one involving a weak, relic poloidal magnetic field trapped inside the radiative zone, which is responsible for expelling differential rotation outwards. This was first proposed by \citet{RK97}. The present work develops this idea with numerical simulations including additional effects like meridional circulation. It is shown that a relic field of 1~Gauss or smaller would be sufficient to explain the observed thickness of the tachocline. The stability of the solar tachocline is addressed as the next part of the problem. It is shown that the tachocline is stable up to a differential rotation of 52\% in the absence of magnetic fields. This is a new finding as compared to the earlier two dimensional models which estimated the solar differential rotation (about 28\%) to be marginally stable or even unstable. The changed stability limit is attributed to the changed stability criterion of the 3-dimensional model which also involves radial gradients of the angular velocity. In the presence of toroidal magnetic field belts, the lowest non-axisymmetric mode is shown to be the most unstable one for the radiative part of the tachocline. It is estimated that the tachocline would become unstable for toroidal fields exceeding about 100~Gauss. With both formation and stability questions satisfactorily addressed, this work presents the most comprehensive analysis of the physical processes in the solar tachocline to date.

Key concepts: Tachocline, Differential rotation, Physics, Convection zone, Solar dynamo, Solar rotation, Magnetohydrodynamics, Helioseismology

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Formation and stability of the solar tachocline in MHD simulations — Research Paper | ScholarLens