2015•ORCA Online Research @Cardiff (Cardiff University)Requires access

The Appropriation of Technology in the Process of an Imposed Organisational Transformation: a Relational Approach

Abdulhafeez Abdullah Alharbi

Open publisher page 0 citations

Abstract

The purpose of this thesis is to contribute to existing explanations of the organisational outcomes of Information Technology (IT). In studying this phenomenon, prior research and theory have taken different approaches. At the one end, technology is seen as a major agent of change determining the structure and behaviour of organisations and their members. In stark opposition to this perspective, the tradition of social construction of technology represents IT outcomes as the product of human interpretations, intentions, and voluntary practices. Recent debates in the field have attempted to go beyond these two extreme positions in order to admit both the role of technology, and the social context into which it is introduced. In line with this emerging literature, this research devises an original conceptual framework to allow for the incorporation of multiple entities and the consideration of the dynamic interaction amongst them. This relational approach is employed to examine IT appropriations and the ensuing organisational change in a case of implementing an IT system in three organisational units of a large airline firm. The evidence from this research reaffirms the significance of human agency in mediating IT outcomes. It also demonstrates how the exercise of agency is informed by both the internal and the external environment of the organisation, as well as by the technology's characteristics. The thesis‘s main contribution is that it provides a sociological account of an instance of IT-associated change that avoids both technological determinism and extreme social constructivism.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

The purpose of this thesis is to contribute to existing explanations of the organisational outcomes of Information Technology (IT). In studying this phenomenon, prior research and theory have taken different approaches. At the one end, technology is seen as a major agent of change determining the structure and behaviour of organisations and their members. In stark opposition to this perspective, the tradition of social construction of technology represents IT outcomes as the product of human interpretations, intentions, and voluntary practices. Recent debates in the field have attempted to go beyond these two extreme positions in order to admit both the role of technology, and the social context into which it is introduced. In line with this emerging literature, this research devises an original conceptual framework to allow for the incorporation of multiple entities and the consideration of the dynamic interaction amongst them. This relational approach is employed to examine IT appropriations and the ensuing organisational change in a case of implementing an IT system in three organisational units of a large airline firm. The evidence from this research reaffirms the significance of human agency in mediating IT outcomes. It also demonstrates how the exercise of agency is informed by both the internal and the external environment of the organisation, as well as by the technology's characteristics. The thesis‘s main contribution is that it provides a sociological account of an instance of IT-associated change that avoids both technological determinism and extreme social constructivism.

Why it matters

A significance statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

The purpose of this thesis is to contribute to existing explanations of the organisational outcomes of Information Technology (IT). In studying this phenomenon, prior research and theory have taken different approaches. At the one end, technology is seen as a major agent of change determining the structure and behaviour of organisations and their members. In stark opposition to this perspective, the tradition of social construction of technology represents IT outcomes as the product of human interpretations, intentions, and voluntary practices. Recent debates in the field have attempted to go beyond these two extreme positions in order to admit both the role of technology, and the social context into which it is introduced. In line with this emerging literature, this research devises an original conceptual framework to allow for the incorporation of multiple entities and the consideration of the dynamic interaction amongst them. This relational approach is employed to examine IT appropriations and the ensuing organisational change in a case of implementing an IT system in three organisational units of a large airline firm. The evidence from this research reaffirms the significance of human agency in mediating IT outcomes. It also demonstrates how the exercise of agency is informed by both the internal and the external environment of the organisation, as well as by the technology's characteristics. The thesis‘s main contribution is that it provides a sociological account of an instance of IT-associated change that avoids both technological determinism and extreme social constructivism.

Key concepts: Appropriation, Technological determinism, Social constructivism, Structure and agency, Determinism, Knowledge management, Agency (philosophy), Phenomenon

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
The Appropriation of Technology in the Process of an Imposed Organisational Transformation: a Relational Approach — Research Paper | ScholarLens