1964•Limnology and OceanographyRequires access

DISTRIBUTION OF NATURAL ISOTOPES OF CARBON IN LINSLEY POND AND OTHER NEW ENGLAND LAKES1

Edward S. Deevey, Minze Stuiver

Open publisher page 95 citations

Abstract

One product of lake metabolism, the CO2 that is produced anaerobically, is naturally labeled by its high C13 content, but in the presence of carbonates, even the modest amounts found in medium‐hard Linsley Pond, such enrichment is not distinctive. Groundwater near the lake is highly charged (175 ml/liter) with CO2; because its source includes ancient carbonate, it is naturally labeled as C14‐poor (Δ=‒87.5‰). Combining these data with estimates of surface inflow, outflow, and other gains and losses of water and carbon, we can account for the C14 deficiency observed in hypolimnetic water (Δ = ca. ‒100‰) by a groundwater contribution of the order of 1 liter/(m2 × day), perhaps less than 1% of the flow expected if the lake were not well insulated by a clay basin seal. Under ice, during the winter of 1961–62, C14 depletion of the deep water developed so rapidly as to suggest direct injection of groundwater and its accumulation by gravitational flow; however, groundwater carbon is ordinarily cycled metabolically, as shown by the fact that organic surface mud has an apparent age of ca. 1,000 years (δC14 = ‒133‰). Inadequate knowledge of the hydrology of Linsley Pond interferes with rigorous description of the carbon balance, as does recent strong but irregular contamination of air by artificial (hydrogen‐bomb) C14. By 1960, submerged pondweeds and surface waters of several lakes were enriched in artificial C14 by less than 5%, while water‐lily leaves, which use atmospheric rather than aquatic sources of carbon, were enriched by ca. 22%. Using the enrichment of Linsley Pond, 1.9% per year, as a tracer, we find the invasion of atmospheric CO2 to be slow, ca. 1.2 moles/(m2 × yr) [1.4 mg/(cm2 × yr)]. Contributions from groundwater and from air being small, and metabolism being an internal cycle that is nearly closed, the carbon balance of a small lake is seen as part of the hydrologic cycle and as dominated by bicarbonate in surface runoff.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

One product of lake metabolism, the CO2 that is produced anaerobically, is naturally labeled by its high C13 content, but in the presence of carbonates, even the modest amounts found in medium‐hard Linsley Pond, such enrichment is not distinctive. Groundwater near the lake is highly charged (175 ml/liter) with CO2; because its source includes ancient carbonate, it is naturally labeled as C14‐poor (Δ=‒87.5‰). Combining these data with estimates of surface inflow, outflow, and other gains and losses of water and carbon, we can account for the C14 deficiency observed in hypolimnetic water (Δ = ca. ‒100‰) by a groundwater contribution of the order of 1 liter/(m2 × day), perhaps less than 1% of the flow expected if the lake were not well insulated by a clay basin seal. Under ice, during the winter of 1961–62, C14 depletion of the deep water developed so rapidly as to suggest direct injection of groundwater and its accumulation by gravitational flow; however, groundwater carbon is ordinarily cycled metabolically, as shown by the fact that organic surface mud has an apparent age of ca. 1,000 years (δC14 = ‒133‰). Inadequate knowledge of the hydrology of Linsley Pond interferes with rigorous description of the carbon balance, as does recent strong but irregular contamination of air by artificial (hydrogen‐bomb) C14. By 1960, submerged pondweeds and surface waters of several lakes were enriched in artificial C14 by less than 5%, while water‐lily leaves, which use atmospheric rather than aquatic sources of carbon, were enriched by ca. 22%. Using the enrichment of Linsley Pond, 1.9% per year, as a tracer, we find the invasion of atmospheric CO2 to be slow, ca. 1.2 moles/(m2 × yr) [1.4 mg/(cm2 × yr)]. Contributions from groundwater and from air being small, and metabolism being an internal cycle that is nearly closed, the carbon balance of a small lake is seen as part of the hydrologic cycle and as dominated by bicarbonate in surface runoff.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 95 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

One product of lake metabolism, the CO2 that is produced anaerobically, is naturally labeled by its high C13 content, but in the presence of carbonates, even the modest amounts found in medium‐hard Linsley Pond, such enrichment is not distinctive. Groundwater near the lake is highly charged (175 ml/liter) with CO2; because its source includes ancient carbonate, it is naturally labeled as C14‐poor (Δ=‒87.5‰). Combining these data with estimates of surface inflow, outflow, and other gains and losses of water and carbon, we can account for the C14 deficiency observed in hypolimnetic water (Δ = ca. ‒100‰) by a groundwater contribution of the order of 1 liter/(m2 × day), perhaps less than 1% of the flow expected if the lake were not well insulated by a clay basin seal. Under ice, during the winter of 1961–62, C14 depletion of the deep water developed so rapidly as to suggest direct injection of groundwater and its accumulation by gravitational flow; however, groundwater carbon is ordinarily cycled metabolically, as shown by the fact that organic surface mud has an apparent age of ca. 1,000 years (δC14 = ‒133‰). Inadequate knowledge of the hydrology of Linsley Pond interferes with rigorous description of the carbon balance, as does recent strong but irregular contamination of air by artificial (hydrogen‐bomb) C14. By 1960, submerged pondweeds and surface waters of several lakes were enriched in artificial C14 by less than 5%, while water‐lily leaves, which use atmospheric rather than aquatic sources of carbon, were enriched by ca. 22%. Using the enrichment of Linsley Pond, 1.9% per year, as a tracer, we find the invasion of atmospheric CO2 to be slow, ca. 1.2 moles/(m2 × yr) [1.4 mg/(cm2 × yr)]. Contributions from groundwater and from air being small, and metabolism being an internal cycle that is nearly closed, the carbon balance of a small lake is seen as part of the hydrologic cycle and as dominated by bicarbonate in surface runoff.

Key concepts: Groundwater, Environmental science, Carbonate, Hydrology (agriculture), Total organic carbon, Surface water, Isotopes of carbon, Outflow

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
DISTRIBUTION OF NATURAL ISOTOPES OF CARBON IN LINSLEY POND AND OTHER NEW ENGLAND LAKES1 — Research Paper | ScholarLens