2010•Journal for Education in the Built EnvironmentOpen access

The Other’s History in Built Environment Education A Case Study: History of Architecture

Zeynep Aygen

Open full text 2 citations

Abstract

If the world of the twenty-first century is indeed a global village, is it not time to sally forth from Fortress Europe and get to know the history and culture of the rest of the world?(Hillenbrand, 2003, p.3)The majority of English textbooks and reference books used in built environment education are limited to Western architecture and its origins. There is a continuing tendency by publishers to introduce new textbooks oriented to a ‘global history of architecture’; however this new genre is still very limited. Consequently History of Architecture and Contemporary Architecture curricula in most English-speaking countries focus on Western and Central Europe and the USA. The exclusion of ‘other’ architectures is largely due to the lack of the teaching material in English; however in some cases it may also have deeper roots within certain cultural perceptions.Beyond History of Architecture, also topics such as Urban Planning, Landscape Architecture and Building Conservation represent the same limitations in spite of a couple exceptions. For example most African national parks in recent years have introduced a sustainable approach to landscape design with their man-made structures from natural materials; however these achievements are usually discussed only in tourism related essays. In the realm of Historic Building Conservation the author has been commissioned recently to write a book about international heritage preservation (Aygen, in press); the book will cover an important gap as there are very few academic publications on this subject area.In most publications and university curricula there is a notable bi-polar approach to certain cultures. If they are mentioned at all, they are labelled as the ‘other’, thereby excluding any synchronic time comparison. Is there any ‘Christian Architecture’ as a discourse opposed to ‘Islamic Architecture’? Why does the ‘Beginnings of Architecture’ generally exclude sites in Asia, Africa and South America? These are some rhetorical questions which need to be answered. The Globalising Art, Architecture and Design History (GLAADH) project, supported by HEFCE, has shown that there is a will to change the existing attitude to ‘other’ architectures, but lack of resource is a limiting factor. This means that there is an urgent need to develop new methodologies for publications in order to enrich the existing built environment curricula in universities.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

If the world of the twenty-first century is indeed a global village, is it not time to sally forth from Fortress Europe and get to know the history and culture of the rest of the world?(Hillenbrand, 2003, p.3)The majority of English textbooks and reference books used in built environment education are limited to Western architecture and its origins. There is a continuing tendency by publishers to introduce new textbooks oriented to a ‘global history of architecture’; however this new genre is still very limited. Consequently History of Architecture and Contemporary Architecture curricula in most English-speaking countries focus on Western and Central Europe and the USA. The exclusion of ‘other’ architectures is largely due to the lack of the teaching material in English; however in some cases it may also have deeper roots within certain cultural perceptions.Beyond History of Architecture, also topics such as Urban Planning, Landscape Architecture and Building Conservation represent the same limitations in spite of a couple exceptions. For example most African national parks in recent years have introduced a sustainable approach to landscape design with their man-made structures from natural materials; however these achievements are usually discussed only in tourism related essays. In the realm of Historic Building Conservation the author has been commissioned recently to write a book about international heritage preservation (Aygen, in press); the book will cover an important gap as there are very few academic publications on this subject area.In most publications and university curricula there is a notable bi-polar approach to certain cultures. If they are mentioned at all, they are labelled as the ‘other’, thereby excluding any synchronic time comparison. Is there any ‘Christian Architecture’ as a discourse opposed to ‘Islamic Architecture’? Why does the ‘Beginnings of Architecture’ generally exclude sites in Asia, Africa and South America? These are some rhetorical questions which need to be answered. The Globalising Art, Architecture and Design History (GLAADH) project, supported by HEFCE, has shown that there is a will to change the existing attitude to ‘other’ architectures, but lack of resource is a limiting factor. This means that there is an urgent need to develop new methodologies for publications in order to enrich the existing built environment curricula in universities.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 2 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

If the world of the twenty-first century is indeed a global village, is it not time to sally forth from Fortress Europe and get to know the history and culture of the rest of the world?(Hillenbrand, 2003, p.3)The majority of English textbooks and reference books used in built environment education are limited to Western architecture and its origins. There is a continuing tendency by publishers to introduce new textbooks oriented to a ‘global history of architecture’; however this new genre is still very limited. Consequently History of Architecture and Contemporary Architecture curricula in most English-speaking countries focus on Western and Central Europe and the USA. The exclusion of ‘other’ architectures is largely due to the lack of the teaching material in English; however in some cases it may also have deeper roots within certain cultural perceptions.Beyond History of Architecture, also topics such as Urban Planning, Landscape Architecture and Building Conservation represent the same limitations in spite of a couple exceptions. For example most African national parks in recent years have introduced a sustainable approach to landscape design with their man-made structures from natural materials; however these achievements are usually discussed only in tourism related essays. In the realm of Historic Building Conservation the author has been commissioned recently to write a book about international heritage preservation (Aygen, in press); the book will cover an important gap as there are very few academic publications on this subject area.In most publications and university curricula there is a notable bi-polar approach to certain cultures. If they are mentioned at all, they are labelled as the ‘other’, thereby excluding any synchronic time comparison. Is there any ‘Christian Architecture’ as a discourse opposed to ‘Islamic Architecture’? Why does the ‘Beginnings of Architecture’ generally exclude sites in Asia, Africa and South America? These are some rhetorical questions which need to be answered. The Globalising Art, Architecture and Design History (GLAADH) project, supported by HEFCE, has shown that there is a will to change the existing attitude to ‘other’ architectures, but lack of resource is a limiting factor. This means that there is an urgent need to develop new methodologies for publications in order to enrich the existing built environment curricula in universities.

Key concepts: Architecture, Curriculum, Built environment, History of architecture, Fortress (chess), Landscape architecture, Cultural heritage, Sociology

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
The Other’s History in Built Environment Education A Case Study: History of Architecture — Research Paper | ScholarLens