2004The Astrophysical JournalOpen access

How Accurately Can We Calculate the Depth of the Solar Convective Zone?

John N. Bahcall, Aldo Serenelli, Marc H. Pinsonneault

Open full text 91 citations

Abstract

We evaluate the logarithmic derivative of the depth of the solar convective zone (CZ) with respect to the logarithm of the radiative opacity, ∂ ln R CZ /∂ ln κ. We use this expression to show that the radiative opacity near the base of the solar CZ must be known to an accuracy of ±1% in order to calculate the CZ depth to the accuracy of the helioseismological measurement, R CZ = 0.713 ± 0.001 R ☉ . The radiative opacity near the base of the CZ that is obtained from OPAL tables must be increased by ~21% in the 2004 Bahcall-Pinsonneault solar model if one wants to invoke opacity errors in order to reconcile recent solar heavy abundance determinations with the helioseismological measurement of R CZ . We show that the radiative opacity near the base of the CZ depends sensitively on the assumed heavy-element mass fraction, Z . The uncertainty in the measured value of Z is currently the limiting factor in our ability to calculate the depth of the CZ. Different state-of-the-art interpolation schemes using the existing OPAL tables yield opacity values that differ by ~4%. We describe the finer grid spacings that are necessary to interpolate the radiative opacity to ±1%. Uncertainties due to the equation of state do not significantly affect the calculated depth of the CZ.

Open-access reader

About this research paper

What this paper is about

We evaluate the logarithmic derivative of the depth of the solar convective zone (CZ) with respect to the logarithm of the radiative opacity, ∂ ln R CZ /∂ ln κ. We use this expression to show that the radiative opacity near the base of the solar CZ must be known to an accuracy of ±1% in order to calculate the CZ depth to the accuracy of the helioseismological measurement, R CZ = 0.713 ± 0.001 R ☉ . The radiative opacity near the base of the CZ that is obtained from OPAL tables must be increased by ~21% in the 2004 Bahcall-Pinsonneault solar model if one wants to invoke opacity errors in order to reconcile recent solar heavy abundance determinations with the helioseismological measurement of R CZ . We show that the radiative opacity near the base of the CZ depends sensitively on the assumed heavy-element mass fraction, Z . The uncertainty in the measured value of Z is currently the limiting factor in our ability to calculate the depth of the CZ. Different state-of-the-art interpolation schemes using the existing OPAL tables yield opacity values that differ by ~4%. We describe the finer grid spacings that are necessary to interpolate the radiative opacity to ±1%. Uncertainties due to the equation of state do not significantly affect the calculated depth of the CZ.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 91 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

We evaluate the logarithmic derivative of the depth of the solar convective zone (CZ) with respect to the logarithm of the radiative opacity, ∂ ln R CZ /∂ ln κ. We use this expression to show that the radiative opacity near the base of the solar CZ must be known to an accuracy of ±1% in order to calculate the CZ depth to the accuracy of the helioseismological measurement, R CZ = 0.713 ± 0.001 R ☉ . The radiative opacity near the base of the CZ that is obtained from OPAL tables must be increased by ~21% in the 2004 Bahcall-Pinsonneault solar model if one wants to invoke opacity errors in order to reconcile recent solar heavy abundance determinations with the helioseismological measurement of R CZ . We show that the radiative opacity near the base of the CZ depends sensitively on the assumed heavy-element mass fraction, Z . The uncertainty in the measured value of Z is currently the limiting factor in our ability to calculate the depth of the CZ. Different state-of-the-art interpolation schemes using the existing OPAL tables yield opacity values that differ by ~4%. We describe the finer grid spacings that are necessary to interpolate the radiative opacity to ±1%. Uncertainties due to the equation of state do not significantly affect the calculated depth of the CZ.

Key concepts: Opacity, Radiative transfer, Physics, Computational physics, Optical depth, Astrophysics, Convection zone, Logarithm

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
How Accurately Can We Calculate the Depth of the Solar Convective Zone? — Research Paper | ScholarLens