Justification for Both Ionic and Thermal Reactions in Grenville Province Pelitic Rocks near Sudbury, Ontario, Canada

Metamorphic reactions related to isograds derived from aluminum silicate-bearing pelitic schists were studied in an area of Grenville Province adjacent to Southern Province rocks near Sudbury, Ontario. Progressing from the northwest to southeast of the area, the meaningful hand-drawn isograds are: (1) sillimanite first occurrence, (2) the last occurrence of staurolite when associated with the entire assemblage, (3) K-feldspar first occurrence, (4) staurolite last occurrence as inclusions in garnet, (5) muscovite last occurrence, and (6) kyanite last occurrence. Whole-rock chemical analysis of 14 representative pelitic schist hand specimens in the area were collected and used to show that metamorphic factors, and not chemical differences, were responsible for the metamorphic isograds. The entire area lies thermally above the melting of rocks of granitic composition. Breakdown curves of the minerals related to the isograds have been used to imply a gradient of 670 °C to 750 °C and 6.3 to 7.3 kilobars, across the area, but the equations for these breakdowns are not entirely substantiated by the modal abundance and textural data.To a first approximation, the rocks may be considered homochemical, but many deviations (due partly to metasomatic change) from this exist. The ionic breakdown of kyanite to muscovite has been shown and an explanation as to why muscovite selectively replaces kyanite and not sillimanite is given. The breakdown of muscovite at the higher grades has been inferred to form K-feldspar, but not sillimanite. Near the kyanite isograd, textures showing the thermal breakdown of kyanite (left over after the partial ionic breakdown of the mineral) to sillimanite are shown. The rocks must have had at least K and possibly Fe added metasomatically to account for the textures shown. From generalized modal abundance surfaces (trend surface analysis), general equations representing the difference in modal abundance of minerals across various isograds were determined and from these, specific equations explaining the breakdown of a particular mineral at its isograd were derived. The most significant of these reactions is the first staurolite isograd, where it is inferred to breakdown in the following way, in the area studied:[Formula: see text]The dissolved Al and Si forms the fibrolite (sillimanite) lenses common in adjacent pelitic rocks