2001Journal of Chemical EducationRequires access

Demonstrating chirality: Using a mirror with physical models to show non-superimposability of chiral molecules with their mirror images

Michael Collins

Open publisher page 5 citations

Abstract

A visually engaging demonstration of molecular chirality uses a mirror and physical models of chiral, achiral, and meso molecules and their mirror images. In the demonstration, a model of a molecule of each type is hidden behind the mirror before class. To demonstrate chirality, the chiral molecule's mirror image is placed in front of the mirror so the class can view its image in the mirror. Standing to one side, the instructor reaches for the molecule in front of the mirror with one hand and simultaneously "reaches into" the mirror with the other hand, in such a way as to make the arm going behind the mirror line up visually with the mirror image of the arm in front of the mirror, to retrieve both the molecule and its "mirror image". This sleight-of-hand operation is visually appealing, and makes the point of mirror images in a memorable fashion.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

A visually engaging demonstration of molecular chirality uses a mirror and physical models of chiral, achiral, and meso molecules and their mirror images. In the demonstration, a model of a molecule of each type is hidden behind the mirror before class. To demonstrate chirality, the chiral molecule's mirror image is placed in front of the mirror so the class can view its image in the mirror. Standing to one side, the instructor reaches for the molecule in front of the mirror with one hand and simultaneously "reaches into" the mirror with the other hand, in such a way as to make the arm going behind the mirror line up visually with the mirror image of the arm in front of the mirror, to retrieve both the molecule and its "mirror image". This sleight-of-hand operation is visually appealing, and makes the point of mirror images in a memorable fashion.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 5 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

A visually engaging demonstration of molecular chirality uses a mirror and physical models of chiral, achiral, and meso molecules and their mirror images. In the demonstration, a model of a molecule of each type is hidden behind the mirror before class. To demonstrate chirality, the chiral molecule's mirror image is placed in front of the mirror so the class can view its image in the mirror. Standing to one side, the instructor reaches for the molecule in front of the mirror with one hand and simultaneously "reaches into" the mirror with the other hand, in such a way as to make the arm going behind the mirror line up visually with the mirror image of the arm in front of the mirror, to retrieve both the molecule and its "mirror image". This sleight-of-hand operation is visually appealing, and makes the point of mirror images in a memorable fashion.

Key concepts: Mirror image, Chirality (physics), Optics, Physics, Point (geometry), Mirror symmetry, Image (mathematics), Curved mirror

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Demonstrating chirality: Using a mirror with physical models to show non-superimposability of chiral molecules with their mirror images — Research Paper | ScholarLens