Effect of combination treatment with entomopathogenic fungi Beauveria bassiana and Nomuraea rileyi (Hypocreales) on Spodoptera litura (Lepidoptera: Noctuidaeae)

In biocontrol of insect pests, efficacy of treatment with multiple pathogens has not been frequently investigated but may have potential for effective management. The possible advantage of a combination treatment with two entomopathogenic fungi – Beauveria bassiana and Nomuraea rileyi – was assessed in laboratory bioassays on second instar Spodoptera litura. From among the fungal isolates of an epizootic population, two isolates of each fungus differing in virulence to S. litura were chosen, one highly virulent and the other with low virulence. The bioassays were carried out at either a continuous temperature of 25±1°C or at a temperature cycle of 32±2°C 8 h/21±2°C 16 h to mimic the field temperatures during the epizootic. Treatments with the two fungi were done both simultaneously and sequentially. In combination treatments at 25±1°C, in all isolate combinations, a majority of the larvae showed N. rileyi induced mycosis; the percentage mortality and speed of kill of insects in these treatments was similar to the N. rileyi isolate used in the combination treatments. At the temperature cycle of 32±2°C 8 h/21±2°C 16 h, in all combination treatments, all the dead insects exhibited B. bassiana mycosis; the mortality pattern was similar to the B. bassiana isolate used in the combination treatments. The adverse effect of high temperature on virulence of N. rileyi was however, not evident in in vitro growth assays. Combination treatment with both fungi did not have a synergistic effect on insect mortality.