Non-existence of a certain projective plane
R. H. F. Denniston
Abstract
Open-access reader
R. H. F. Denniston
Abstract
Open-access reader
The question whether any projective plane of order ten exists or not, is an unsolved problem that has attracted some interest (see, for instance, [2]). A method, by which a plane might have been discovered, was suggested to me by a theorem in [1]: ‘If order of a plane is greater than 10, a six-arc is not complete’. Elementary arguments do not, it appears, exclude the possibility of a complete six-arc in a plane of order ten: but they do show that such a figure would be of an extreme type, and that the whole plane would fit round it in a particular way. The limitation, in fact, is so severe that it becomes feasible to consider, for a good many of the incidences in the plane, all the alternative arrangements that seem possible. With the help of the Elliott 4130 computer of the University of Leicester, I have carried out an exhaustive search, and discovered that it is impossible to build up a projective plane by this method. So I can assert:
OpenAlex reports 20 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.
A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.
Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.
The question whether any projective plane of order ten exists or not, is an unsolved problem that has attracted some interest (see, for instance, [2]). A method, by which a plane might have been discovered, was suggested to me by a theorem in [1]: ‘If order of a plane is greater than 10, a six-arc is not complete’. Elementary arguments do not, it appears, exclude the possibility of a complete six-arc in a plane of order ten: but they do show that such a figure would be of an extreme type, and that the whole plane would fit round it in a particular way. The limitation, in fact, is so severe that it becomes feasible to consider, for a good many of the incidences in the plane, all the alternative arrangements that seem possible. With the help of the Elliott 4130 computer of the University of Leicester, I have carried out an exhaustive search, and discovered that it is impossible to build up a projective plane by this method. So I can assert:
Key concepts: Projective plane, Plane (geometry), Mathematics, Order (exchange), Plane curve, Blocking set, Arc (geometry), Line at infinity