1979Journal of Geophysical Research AtmospheresRequires access

Comparison of gravimetric geoids with Geos 3 altimetric geoid

Michael E. Chapman, Manik Talwani

Open publisher page 31 citations

Abstract

By means of 1° × 1° gravimetric geoids in the North Atlantic, Northwest Pacific, and Indian oceans, comparisons have been made with Geos 3 radar altimeter estimates of geoid height. Most commonly, there are constant offsets and long‐wavelength discrepancies between the two data sets; there are many probable causes, including radial orbit error, scale errors in the geoid, or bias errors in altitude determination. Across the Aleutian trench the 1° × 1° gravimetric geoids do not measure the entire depth of the geoid anomaly. This is due to averaging over 1° squares and subsequent aliasing of the data. Especially above trench systems in the Pacific, there can be considerable energy in the geoid for frequencies higher than are resolvable by 1° × 1° geoids; such a signal, though, is detected by the Geos 3 altimeter. After adjustment of Geos 3 data to eliminate long‐wavelength discrepancies, agreement between the altimeter geoid and gravimetric geoid is between 1.7 and 2.7 m in rms error. In a hypothetical experiment a comparison can be made of an altimeter determining the geoid and a gravimeter measuring gravity. At longer wavelengths an altimeter will have a higher signal to noise ratio, but at shorter wavelengths a gravimeter will perform better.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

By means of 1° × 1° gravimetric geoids in the North Atlantic, Northwest Pacific, and Indian oceans, comparisons have been made with Geos 3 radar altimeter estimates of geoid height. Most commonly, there are constant offsets and long‐wavelength discrepancies between the two data sets; there are many probable causes, including radial orbit error, scale errors in the geoid, or bias errors in altitude determination. Across the Aleutian trench the 1° × 1° gravimetric geoids do not measure the entire depth of the geoid anomaly. This is due to averaging over 1° squares and subsequent aliasing of the data. Especially above trench systems in the Pacific, there can be considerable energy in the geoid for frequencies higher than are resolvable by 1° × 1° geoids; such a signal, though, is detected by the Geos 3 altimeter. After adjustment of Geos 3 data to eliminate long‐wavelength discrepancies, agreement between the altimeter geoid and gravimetric geoid is between 1.7 and 2.7 m in rms error. In a hypothetical experiment a comparison can be made of an altimeter determining the geoid and a gravimeter measuring gravity. At longer wavelengths an altimeter will have a higher signal to noise ratio, but at shorter wavelengths a gravimeter will perform better.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 31 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

By means of 1° × 1° gravimetric geoids in the North Atlantic, Northwest Pacific, and Indian oceans, comparisons have been made with Geos 3 radar altimeter estimates of geoid height. Most commonly, there are constant offsets and long‐wavelength discrepancies between the two data sets; there are many probable causes, including radial orbit error, scale errors in the geoid, or bias errors in altitude determination. Across the Aleutian trench the 1° × 1° gravimetric geoids do not measure the entire depth of the geoid anomaly. This is due to averaging over 1° squares and subsequent aliasing of the data. Especially above trench systems in the Pacific, there can be considerable energy in the geoid for frequencies higher than are resolvable by 1° × 1° geoids; such a signal, though, is detected by the Geos 3 altimeter. After adjustment of Geos 3 data to eliminate long‐wavelength discrepancies, agreement between the altimeter geoid and gravimetric geoid is between 1.7 and 2.7 m in rms error. In a hypothetical experiment a comparison can be made of an altimeter determining the geoid and a gravimeter measuring gravity. At longer wavelengths an altimeter will have a higher signal to noise ratio, but at shorter wavelengths a gravimeter will perform better.

Key concepts: Geoid, Altimeter, Geodesy, Geology, Undulation of the geoid, Radar altimeter, Gravimeter, Ocean surface topography

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
Comparison of gravimetric geoids with Geos 3 altimetric geoid — Research Paper | ScholarLens