Overlapping of Thick Film NTC Thermistors and Resistors: A Way to Optimise Laser Trimming of Narrow Tolerance NTC Thermistors

The direct overlapping of thick film NTC thermistors and resistors was attempted to enable the trimming of NTC thermistors to relatively narrow tolerances with little influence on beta factors. Different combinations of 1 kohm/□ thick film NTC material (4993, Remex) and 1 and 10 kohm/□RuO2 and ruthenate based thick film resistors (HS-80 series, Du Pont), fired either together or separately, were tested. The sheet resistivities, TCR and beta factors of these combinations were measured. Microstructures were investigated by SEM and analysed by EDS. The results, i.e., the large decrease of sheet resistivities (up to ten times) and a resistivity vs. temperature dependence which changed from negative to positive TCR for some combinations, indicate the interaction between NTC materials and resistors during the firing process. These interactions are more distinctive for materials fired together. In all cases the beta factors were lower than calculated. Based on these experiments, the ‘best’ thick film resistor paste for NTC/resistor combination (HS-8041, Du Pont) was chosen. Several layouts with partially or entirely overlapped NTC thermistors/resistors were designed. Unprotected, glass protected or organic protected circuits were laser trimmed. The resistivities and beta factors were measured as a function of resistor geometries and laser cut lengths. The results obtained demonstrated that NTC thermistors, partially overprinted with an ‘ordinary’ thick film resistor, can be trimmed to tolerances around 0.5% without any special precautions during trimming.