2000International Journal for Numerical Methods in FluidsOpen access

One‐dimensional finite element grids based on a localized truncation error analysis

Scott C. Hagen, Joannes J. Westerink, Randall L. Kolar

Open full text 43 citations

Abstract

With the exponential increase in computing power, modelers of coastal and oceanic regions are capable of simulating larger domains with increased resolution. Typically, these models use graded meshes wherein the size of the elements can vary by orders of magnitude. However, with notably few exceptions, the graded meshes are generated using criteria that neither optimize placement of the node points nor properly incorporate the physics, as represented by discrete equations, underlying tidal flow and circulation to the mesh generation process. Consequently, the user of the model must heuristically adjust such meshes based on knowledge of local flow and topographical features—a rough and time consuming proposition at best. Herein, a localized truncation error analysis (LTEA) is proposed as a means to efficiently generate meshes that incorporate estimates of flow variables and their derivatives. In a one-dimensional (1D) setting, three different LTEA-based finite element grid generation methodologies are examined and compared with two common algorithms: the wavelength to Δx ratio criterion and the topographical length scale criterion. Errors are compared on a per node basis. It is shown that solutions based on LTEA meshes are, in general, more accurate (both locally and globally) and more efficient. In addition, the study shows that the first four terms of the ordered truncation error series are in direct competition and, subsequently, that the leading order term of the truncation error series is not necessarily the dominant term. Analyses and results from this 1D study lay the groundwork for developing an efficient mesh generating algorithm suitable for two-dimensional (2D) models. Copyright © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

About this research paper

What this paper is about

With the exponential increase in computing power, modelers of coastal and oceanic regions are capable of simulating larger domains with increased resolution. Typically, these models use graded meshes wherein the size of the elements can vary by orders of magnitude. However, with notably few exceptions, the graded meshes are generated using criteria that neither optimize placement of the node points nor properly incorporate the physics, as represented by discrete equations, underlying tidal flow and circulation to the mesh generation process. Consequently, the user of the model must heuristically adjust such meshes based on knowledge of local flow and topographical features—a rough and time consuming proposition at best. Herein, a localized truncation error analysis (LTEA) is proposed as a means to efficiently generate meshes that incorporate estimates of flow variables and their derivatives. In a one-dimensional (1D) setting, three different LTEA-based finite element grid generation methodologies are examined and compared with two common algorithms: the wavelength to Δx ratio criterion and the topographical length scale criterion. Errors are compared on a per node basis. It is shown that solutions based on LTEA meshes are, in general, more accurate (both locally and globally) and more efficient. In addition, the study shows that the first four terms of the ordered truncation error series are in direct competition and, subsequently, that the leading order term of the truncation error series is not necessarily the dominant term. Analyses and results from this 1D study lay the groundwork for developing an efficient mesh generating algorithm suitable for two-dimensional (2D) models. Copyright © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Why it matters

OpenAlex reports 43 citations for this work. Citation counts describe recorded attention and do not establish research quality.

Key contribution

A contribution statement is not available in the OpenAlex record.

Method / approach

Method details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Main findings

Findings are not separately available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Limitations

Limitations are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Applications

Application details are not available in the OpenAlex metadata.

Available abstract

With the exponential increase in computing power, modelers of coastal and oceanic regions are capable of simulating larger domains with increased resolution. Typically, these models use graded meshes wherein the size of the elements can vary by orders of magnitude. However, with notably few exceptions, the graded meshes are generated using criteria that neither optimize placement of the node points nor properly incorporate the physics, as represented by discrete equations, underlying tidal flow and circulation to the mesh generation process. Consequently, the user of the model must heuristically adjust such meshes based on knowledge of local flow and topographical features—a rough and time consuming proposition at best. Herein, a localized truncation error analysis (LTEA) is proposed as a means to efficiently generate meshes that incorporate estimates of flow variables and their derivatives. In a one-dimensional (1D) setting, three different LTEA-based finite element grid generation methodologies are examined and compared with two common algorithms: the wavelength to Δx ratio criterion and the topographical length scale criterion. Errors are compared on a per node basis. It is shown that solutions based on LTEA meshes are, in general, more accurate (both locally and globally) and more efficient. In addition, the study shows that the first four terms of the ordered truncation error series are in direct competition and, subsequently, that the leading order term of the truncation error series is not necessarily the dominant term. Analyses and results from this 1D study lay the groundwork for developing an efficient mesh generating algorithm suitable for two-dimensional (2D) models. Copyright © 2000 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Key concepts: Truncation error, Truncation (statistics), Finite element method, Mathematics, Applied mathematics, Mesh generation, Error analysis, Computational fluid dynamics

Related papers

Back to paper searchBrowse research topicsOriginal source
One‐dimensional finite element grids based on a localized truncation error analysis — Research Paper | ScholarLens